Doki Doki Literature Club - Why Spoilers Don't Matter

 Doki Doki Literature Club goes wrong.  This is not a surprise in the slightest at this point, this is objectively the most famous thing abo...

Showing posts with label Art. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Art. Show all posts

Wednesday, November 11, 2026

Skyrim is a bad RPG

On November 11th, 2011 the Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim released.  To say it was huge would be an understatement.  At the time that Skyrim released, Bethesda were still the golden boys of the games industry.  The company by gamers, for gamers.  Bethesda were beloved in 2011, of the major Triple A devs not even Nintendo had as passionate or devoted a fanbase.  Bethesda was famous for its good relationship with its community, open support for people who mod their games at a time when companies were all trying to be exceptionally predatory with DRM as the PC market grew into the mainstream, and, most importantly, for kickstarting a mainstream surge for a very specific kind of RPG.

The more Western style of RPGs had always been relatively popular, but it had issues breaking through to the mainstream.  Titles like Baldur's Gate were locked to the very humble PC market in a time before we had a massive uptick in PC gaming.  Consoles, which at the time were significantly more popular than PCs as a way to game, were just ill-equipped for the kind of RPGs that were being designed in the west.  They were often very mechanically complicated and ridiculously in-depth games that benefitted from mouse and keyboard controls and would not particularly fit well to controllers.  They were often inspired or directly made out of systems similar to DnD, with incredibly in-depth stat screens and character creation and gameplay that could be best described as "simulating dice rolls".

Console versions of these PC RPG series would very often take the form of spinoffs, action-role-playing games that invoke a more hack-and-slash style of tactics RPGs which try to invoke the gameplay of these titles by having more grid based gameplay and less emphasis on player autonomy.  The RPGs that were typically big on console were, instead, from Japan mostly.  Games that have a more simplified, intuitive core gameplay where complexity comes from digging in-depth into what appear as simple system, as well as having a heavier focus on the player as a bystander experiencing the story rather than direct player autonomy within it.  Some more Western style RPGs would get massive on consoles, don't get me wrong, the Knights of the Old Republic games were originally Xbox console exclusives, and were Xbox exclusive period for the first several months of their lifespan.  But, for many generations, it seemed like the PC was the domain of the Western RPG and console was the domain of the East.

Bethesda, more than anyone, changed this perception.  With titles like Morrowind, Oblivion, and most importantly, Fallout 3, Bethesda took this style of RPG and made it mainstream.  By taking influence from action-adventure games, first person shooters, and more console-focused RPGs, Bethesda created a solution that would adapt this very Dungeons and Dragons-y design into something more palatable for a wider audience.  It was not a translation without controversy, mind you.  Bethesda has long been criticized for creating games are too in line with console gamers' needs, removing a lot of the complexity of the previous PC-focused entries in these franchise.  But, it was ultimately a decision that resulted in an overall positive reception from both critics and audiences, with games like Oblivion and Fallout 3 often being ranked among the greatest games ever made.  Bethesda, in a lot of ways, made the public fall in love with RPGs as a genre, and we still see the effects of this decision all these years later.  Basically every game, especially every open world game, has extensive RPG elements to it.

No Bethesda game is as famous or iconic, though, as the fifth entry in the Elder Scrolls series, Skyrim.  Released on 11-11-11, still a killer release date, Skyrim very quickly became one of THE video games.  Everyone has heard of Skyrim, the vast majority of gamers have played some version of it, and it is one of the best-selling video games of all time (65 million copies sold as of 2026, making it tied for the 8th best-selling video game ever made).  It is one of the most important RPGs of all time, one of the most iconic fantasy games of all time, and it is a game that, if you play video games, is a must-play.  It is as important to the canon of video games as the Legend of Zelda, so much so that back in the day a very common "who would win" matchup was to pit the Dovakiin against the grandfather of fantasy video games.  An absurd matchup as the Dragonborn can't do more than like a heart to Link at any given time but Link can drain his HP down with a single spin attack.

I was part of the Skyrim hype train once upon a time.  I never owned it myself, mind you, I didn't have a console that could play it until 2016-ish and by that time I had already come to my conclusions about Skyrim as a video game.  But from 2011 until then, playing through a bunch of Skyrim was a common activity when I would stay over at friends houses or when I moved in with my first roommate and he brought his PS3 with him.  Shoutouts to my Khajit mage that I'm sure I gave a dumb name but lord knows I'll never remember it.  I have played a lot of Skyrim over my life, I've had multiple files that have gone for at least 20 hours apiece and I even almost beat the game on one of my files. It was my first time ever playing a game like this, a massive open world that you could just explore around.  It's never been a game I loved, mind you, I always found the map incredibly difficult to navigate and the enemy variety sorely lacking.  But I did really enjoy it for much of my life.  But, eventually I stopped playing it.  Played a bunch of other games in the same genre.  Sat with my opinions on Skyrim for a while.  And I, eventually, came to a conclusion on my feelings about the game...

Skyrim is a bad RPG.

Skill Trees

I want to start by discussing Skyrim's level-up and Skill tree system, not necessarily because I think it is bad, but because I think it is an important baseline to understand many of my later criticisms with the game.  To be honest, I actually do rather like Skyrim's core level up system, at least in theory.  So, Skyrim at its core has a fairly standard EXP system.  As you defeat enemies, complete quests, and find new areas within the continent of Skyrim, you will gain experience which will eventually result in a level up.  Upon the level up, you will be able to increase your stats and gain a skill point for the game's skill tree(s).  What Skyrim lacks, however, is a traditional stat system.  Stats you would commonly associate with an RPG (Strength, Magic, Defense, etc.) are absent from the Elder Scrolls V, with the only stats the player can increase upon level-up being their HP, their mana, and their Stamina.  So how, pray tell, do you become better at, say, swordfighting without strength, or magic without intelligence, or stealth without dexterity?  Simple: you level up the specific skill itself.

Skyrim has a very in-depth skill tree system.  At any time in the game, but most importantly upon level up, you access the various constellations that are found above the continent Skyrim, with a bevvy of skill points you've amassed from level ups in tow.  The skill points can be used to access the stars in each of the constellations, of which there are 18, 6 under each vague umbrella of a class system.  They are as follows:

  • Illusion - Magics focusing on altered perceptions, either being magic where you change the enemies mood/mind (things like Calm removing their aggression or Frenzy forcing them to go into a blind rage) or Magics which can obscure the user in some way (Invisibility turning them briefly invisible or Muffle hiding the sounds of their movement).
  • Conjuration - Magics focused on conjuring things to reality, either by summoning mystical weaponry of other types on the skill tree (Blades, Maces, Bows) or by summoning Familiars to aid you in combat (Wolves, Golems, Fire Women).
  • Destruction - Magics focused on pure damage, these are the primary offensive magics in the game and come in three elemental categories, Fire magic (most cost effective, average speed, average damage, usually grant a damage over time effect), Frost magic (average cost effectiveness, slow speed, assaults the enemy stamina as well as health, slows enemy movement), and Shock magic (least cost effective, instant speed, high damage, assaults the enemy magic as well as health).
  • Restoration - Healing and Defensive magic, the prototypical "white magic".  It specializes in either direct healing magic, wards that act as magical shields the caster has to actively maintain, or magic dealing with harming the undead.
  • Alteration - Magic dealing with adding or changing things to the physical world, primarily used for armor spells which turn the caster's skin into resilient material (Wood, Stone, Dragonhide) but also includes things such as creating magical lights or transmuting iron into gold.
  • Enchanting - Dealing with imbuing weapons and armor with magical abilities, such as elemental properties, calming or frenzying enemies, or even stealing souls.
  • Archery - Dealing with fighting with bows and arrows.
  • Block - Dealing with shields and defensive stances in melee combat.
  • Heavy Armor - Dealing with bulkier, more defensive, heavier armors types like plate, bone, or dragon.
  • One-Handed - Dealing with one-handed weaponry, things like swords, maces, daggers, and any related weapons that you could either dual-wield or wield with a shield.
  • Smithing - Dealing with weapon and armorcraft, smelting, pounding, and honing your own blades, shields, and armors from materials you find while adventuring.
  • Two-Handed - Dealing with two-handed weaponry, things like battleaxes, warhammers and greatswords, weapons that require both hands to use.
  • Alchemy - Dealing with the creation of potions and poisons by mixing various natural ingredients into bottles.
  • Light Armor - Dealing with lighter, less defensive, easier to move in armor, such as hide, chain, or leather.
  • Lockpicking - Dealing with picking locks.
  • Pickpocket - Dealing with stealing directly from the pockets of people.
  • Sneak - Dealing with all things stealth, successfully hiding after being detected, sneaking around people without being detected at all, doing sneak attacks such as stealth kills and sniper shots with a bow, things of that nature.
  • Speech - Essentially your charisma stat, Speech deals with persuasion and intimidation checks and what kind of deals you get from the shops (i.e., a higher Speech stat means you will be able to buy for less and sell for more).

As you level up, you will be able to expend your skill points to pick perks from these various skill trees.  Some of these are technically unnecessary but are beneficial to the point of necessity, the magic skill trees, for instance, all have half Mana cost for the respective spell type and spell level as a skill path, which is useful as naturally magic tends to take up more mana than you are likely to have at any point in the game.  Others represent a skill's literal progression system, the Smithing system will lock the ability to make better weapons and armor from you until you progress in the skill tree.  And still others are just for fun, like the Lockpicking skill that ensures your lockpicks won't break.

But, you don't simply just choose your perks upon level up, nor is there some sort of overall level lock on certain skills.  Instead, you have to actively use the skills you wish to level up.  Each skill has its own level up system that goes up when you engage with it, i.e. using destruction magic levels up your destruction, smithing weapons and armor levels up your smithing, etc.  This means the player is actively being incentivized to, a, develop a unique build of their own, b, engage with their specific build and not try to be too much of an all-arounder, and c, make decisions on how to play the game based on what their build actually is.  If you're specializing in Speech, you'll want to try and persuade or intimidate your way past problems rather than try to solve them in more traditional ways.  If you're a mage, you're more likely to find creative solutions with the environment rather than trying to engage with combat.

In theory, Skyrim's core system is genius.  It's very intuitive, a very simple cause and effect, but it allows the player a lot of freedom to craft their character and their build however they see fit.  It doesn't impose any specific, predetermined build on you, starting every skill on even ground and telling you to find your own path.  But there are also direct consequences to how you build, investing in builds takes time and so you will naturally want to invest in a certain play style, as you will directly benefit from honing in on your chosen stat spread.  This means, hypothetically, that you are locking yourself into what content your capable of doing by choosing what you wish to focus on.  If you are a dedicated mage, you will naturally shy away from questlines that focus on more aggressive, direct gameplay styles.  It is, in theory, an excellent RPG skill/stat system, what that makes you choose your build and live with the consequences of doing so.  It is the core from which Skyrim could build a generationally brilliant RPG, one that allows creativity with one's builds but forces them to live with what they choose to focus on.  It is the potential that Skyrim will fail to live up to in every other facet of its design.

Race

Skyrim's character creator is incredibly in-depth.  While nowadays it is very common for character creators to have features like "adjusting the specific angle of your eyebrows to the most minute degree", upon Skyrim's release this was actually pretty revolutionary.  The ability to create whatever nightmare demon comes to your head was novel at the time, and who knows, maybe you could even defy the odds and make a character that looks good.  It could happen, you never know.  But the first selection you must make is choosing your fantasy race.  And it is here that we start to see how Skyrim's systems conflict with one another.

There are ten races to choose from in Skyrim's character creator, each representing one of the ten living races in the world of the Elder Scrolls series.  There are the more "human" races of the world, the Nords, Bretons, Imperials, and Redguard, who are roughly analogous to the Germanic/Norse people, the Britannic/Gaelic people, the Mediterranean people, and the West African people of our world.  There are the elven races of the world of the Elder Scrolls series, the High Elves, Wood Elves, Dark Elves, and Orcs, who are very in line with many classic fantasy races.  And there are the entirely unique races of the Argonians and the Khajit, the former being a reptilian race of swamp-dwellers and the latter are a race of desert-dwelling cat people, both of whom are traditionally looked down upon by the other races in Skyrim for racist reasons.

Picking your race is not simply a cosmetic choice, nor is it a bit of flavor to add to your character.  Your race matters for gameplay reasons.  Each race starts with several boons.  They each have a passive ability that is unique to their race.  Argonians resist disease, Khajit get an attack buff when fighting in hand to hand combat, Nords resist the cold, stuff like that.  Each race has at least one passive ability, with several of the races getting multiple passives and the Argonians getting up to four (although they are all situationally useful at best).  Except Orcs, Orcs accidentally didn't get a passive until the special edition rerelease added a Survival mode.  Each race also has a unique active ability, something that can be activated once per day to aid them in their quest.  Orcs get a "deal double damage" buff, Wood Elves can turn an animal into an ally, Imperials can cast Calm, etc.  But the most notable thing about choosing your race is how it buffs your starting stat spread.

Every single race in Skyrim starts with deterministic stats, a stat spread that starts out with boons to stats that are associated with your race.  Every single race has a +10 to one specific skill and a +5 to five others, usually skills that would be relevant to certain play styles.  High Elves start with boons in every magic stat, with a +10 to Illusion, Redguards start with +5 to skills that would benefit a sword-and-sorcery play style with a +10 to one-handed, Dark Elves start with stat benefits in a mix of magic and sneaking stats with a +10 to Destruction magic.  Stuff like that.  You gain direct gameplay benefits for choosing a specific race that go beyond simple passive boons and/or interesting worldbuilding implications that would directly benefit your role-playing.

Now, I do not want to enter into the debate on whether or not deterministic stats are good or not.  I am not a TTRPG player, I have limited experience with systems that have them, other than Skyrim my only experience with it was Baldur's Gate II where I had to play an Orc Shaman because the game wouldn't let me be an Orc Wild Mage like I wanted.  I could see arguments for and against them, but it's really not my place to have an opinion on whether this is something that should be in games.  Leave that to the people who actually deal with them on the reg, you know?

Rather, I want to focus on an immediate conflict between Skyrim's skill system and Skyrim's race system.  One of the things I lauded the former for was how it gave the player just enough freedom.  It starts in a neutral state and allows the player to form their own gameplay identity through how they engage with the game's systems.  It is non-deterministic, it is designed to ensure the player has the ability to play their way.  The race system, meanwhile, is very deterministic.  It is leading the player onto a specific path right from the start based on what they want their character to be.  If you looked at Dark Elves and thought "wow, this is such a cool thing to be, I want to be a cool Dark Elf", you are starting with a mix of stealth and magic stats whether or not you were thinking of being a Dark Elf Warrior who beheads enemies with a massive battleaxe.

Now, I'm not going to sit here and tell you that the game is forcing you into the boxes determined by your chosen race's default stats.  That would be lying.  The game is starting you out with a potentially beneficial stat spread, a starting build which one may find compelling but can ignore as they wish.  If you want to play as an Orc mage and basically look like Travis Willingham next to all his co-stars, go for it, you do you.  However, I do think it's notable how much these boons make or break the early game for your intended play style.  That additional 5 points is the difference between being able to start off with a better perk in a given skill and having to level that skill up more to earn it.  And for a lot of these skills, being able to start out with a higher level perk is massive.  It is the backbone of a mage-focused play style, as magic is very costly and being able to reduce spell cost by half is practically the only way to make mage gameplay sustainable.  Skills like Pickpocketing are nearly impossible to do without the perks to give you higher success rates.

The game isn't telling you to play any specific play style, but it is nudging you into the boxes that it has crafted for you by giving you too many good reasons to connect with a certain build based on your race.  It is telling you "do whatever you like with your build" and also making it so that you are heavily incentivized to prebuild because the advantages you gain from it are too massive to ignore.  You certainly can be an Orc mage if that's what you desire, but also you might want to reconsider and play High Elf if you want to do magic, it'll be more efficient that way.  It is telling you to play the game your way and also play the game its way.

The Class System is(n't) Real

If you have been paying attention, you'll have intuited that the various skills of Skyrim are kind of under three umbrellas.  Magic skills, combat skills, and stealth skills.  One might even say that these skills roughly translate to the three archetypal RPG classes.  Warriors, Mages, and Rogues.  This is not a coincidence.  Skyrim utilizes the trappings of traditional RPG classes in order to make a very intuitive system for the player to conceptualize how each skill is intended to be used.  It's not a hard and fast rule, mind you, again you have the freedom to build however you want, but it is a structure that Skyrim places to easily communicate what skills are best suited for what play style.  Rest assured, dear reader, Skyrim does not have a class system.  Well it does but not an RPG class system, the societal class system is a very important note in Skyrim.

There are seven skills under each umbrella, with five unique to the "class" at hand and two that are transitional between classes on the level up screen.  Mages receive Alchemy, Alteration, Illusion, Conjuration, Destruction, Restoration and Enchanting.  All very obvious magic related skills.  Warriors receive Enchanting, Heavy Armor, Block, Two-Handed, One-Handed, Smithing. and Archery.  Primarily combat related skills all put under the umbrella of "Warrior", with a couple of the crafting and physical defense related skills for good measure.  And finally, the Rogue umbrella, which is Archery, Speech, Sneak, Pickpocketing, Lockpicking, Light Armor, and Alchemy.  All the sneakier, stealth based skills, stuff that is about stealing, charisma, and subterfuge.  But, this is all this is.  Just umbrellas for easy communication to the player.  After all, there is no class system in Skyrim, it's all about the freedom to make your own unique build, you know?

So after you finish the tutorial you encounter the class system in Skyrim.  Assuming you follow the path laid out in front of you by the person you escape the tutorial with and don't just decide to go off on your adventure, you will quickly come across a group of stones with runes on them.  These stones are "Standing Stones", enchanted stones scattered throughout Skyrim that when interacted with will grant the player a passive buff until they interact with another Standing Stone, which will then remove the buff.  The majority of these stones are more specific buffs, one of them allows you to gain serpent venom to your attacks once per day, one of them increases magic recovery, etc., but this grouping hold a very specific purpose.  They grant you a 20% experience buff to any skill under one of the three umbrellas.

Now, again, you can simply choose not to gain a buff here.  Or, if you know what will be the most beneficial for your build, you can choose to gain one of these buffs, level it up for a little while, and come get another.  These are not hard and fast classes, it is not locking you into a specific set of skills by choosing your "class".  But once again, we are seeing the game push you towards a direction when it also touts that you have a freedom to choose your build.  This 20% buff is not-negligible, skills, especially Thief skills, level up very quickly at first but begin to plateau as soon as you reach the mid 30s in your skill level.  Without this 20% buff, it's very likely you will go hours of gameplay without a single skill level up, it matters a lot.

The game is encouraging you to by very extremist with your build, to play full Warrior, full Mage, full Thief.  It's not something you have to do, but it is something you'll want to do.  And not only does this conflict with the game's promise of full control over what role you will play, but it also conflicts with races having deterministic stats in the first place.  Many races are designed to benefit mixed builds, lots of mage + thief skills and warrior + mage skills.  Only Orcs, High Elves, and Wood Elves are built for one specific class.  The game has nudged you in three directions with how your character will start out.  It grants you complete freedom over what skills you want to level up, but then tells you "hey, since you're playing this character, you should probably use this combination of skills" implying what your build should be, only to then also be like "but we also would really like you to do a very traditional class system if you want to see any worthwhile gains on any of your skills".  And the freedom it grants you is also the freedom to choose not to engage with these systems, not to let the game dictate your play style.  But if you make it so that you clearly want the player to stay in the box, giving them ample food and a steady stream of water, saying "the player can leave the box whenever they would like" doesn't count as a defense.

The Guild

As we've just established, Skyrim has a class system.  It's not one you technically have to abide by, but it's there.  You are heavily incentivized to build around both your race and a certain class as the potential benefits from doing so are so massive that it is difficult to justify playing another way.  To compound onto this problem, however, we have the guilds.  Skyrim, like a lot of fantasy RPGs, has a guild system.  A place for adventurers to gather, find a safe place to rest, meet fellow adventurers who maybe looking for an adventuring party to join up with, and take odd jobs for some extra gold.  It's a very common and very useful system to include in an RPG where progression is constant but your opportunities to gain more gold may not be.

Skyrim has three such guilds.  I guess it actually has four, but the fourth one is less a "guild" and more a "Dark Urge path".  There are the Companions of central Skyrim, a band of warriors who fight hard and drink harder and are likely to be the first guild you encounter within the game.  There is the Thieves' Guild in southern Skyrim, a network of thieves and fences who are trying to regain their glory as an organized crime unit.  And there is the College of Winterhold in the icy north of Skyrim, a mage college where mages can go to learn and increase their magical powers.  Three distinctive guilds to represent the three classes of Skyrim.  Once again, incentivizing playing by their rules despite their promises of freedom.

Now, as always, you don't have to do any of this.  Two of the three guilds are very out of the way from the majority of where you will be spending the game, as the hub of Skyrim's content is very focused in the middle and western parts of Skyrim.  It is very out of the way to even find the guilds in the first place, much less join them.  And, I'll grant them, that joining the guilds is a less restrictive process than them being tied to a class system makes it seem like they would be.  You can join the Warrior's guild no matter what your build probably is because the only check to join it is moderately difficult one on one sword fight.  Which is likely to be a skill you have some expertise in as you find this area early enough in the game to where you probably haven't carved out your build and are reliant on melee weaponry.  The mages guild and thieves guild have similar fairly easy checks for membership.  You don't have to be specialized in any class to access this content.

But we are once again seeing the game attempt to have its cake and eat it too.  It wants you to both have the freedom to build however you want while also pushing you into very predetermined, traditionalist directions with how you play the game.  It wants to simplify the experience for an audience that may have never played a fantasy RPG before, establish the basics for them in particular, while also attempting to give the player complete freedom to explore that complexity.  It wants to be everything for everyone, it wants to both tell the player how they should play and also tell them there is no right way to play.  The Guilds are three of the biggest questlines in Skyrim, a substantial part of the game's content is locked behind a traditional class system, and while you can certainly find enough to do without doing any of them, without playing by the paths the game lays out for you, it's clear it wants you to play by its rules.  It doesn't necessarily stamp on your freedom, but it seems like it's putting up a bunch of fences and telling you "you can jump them if you want".

Skyrim Is For the Nords

The very first NPC you meet in Skyrim is a man by the name of Ulfric Stormcloak.  Literally, Ulfric is a face you meet so early that you don't have one yet.  Your character has not made it to the character creation screen before you meet Ulfric Stormcloak.  Ulfric is a prisoner, part of a wagon heading to a stronghold in the center of Skyrim to prepare for execution.  Ulfric's crime is treason, he has recently executed the King of Skyrim and started a civil war within the continent.  The reason being that Ulfric truly hates the governance of Skyrim

Ulfric believes ruling Skyrim is his birthright, that as the last descendant of an ancient bloodline within Skyrim that is so old that it traces back to the dragons who used to rule this land he should be on the throne, and that the current rulers of Skyrim are little more than puppets to a great empire.  Ulfric wishes to bring back a golden age of Skyrim, one where the people are in charge rather than some foreign empire.  He wants to reclaim Skyrim for its indigenous people, the Nords, and rule it as the rightful king.  And also he's a massive racist who finds other races besides the Nords to be at best necessary evils and at worse trespassers on the sacred lands of his ancestors.  Ulfric does not simply believe Skyrim should belong to its native people, he believes that it should ONLY be inhabited by its native people.  So goes his rallying cry.  "Skyrim is for the Nords".

One of the biggest questlines in the game gives you the option to agree with him.  There is a lot that can be said about the Civil War storyline in Skyrim.  In my mind, it is a incredibly unnuanced look at a volatile political situation that fails to really make a case for either side being better for the land of Skyrim in any significant way, as it ultimately makes both the Empire and the Stormcloak rebellion motivated by a singular trait that is unambiguously vile.  The Empire are authoritarians who rule with a heavy hand and literally have a secret government with potentially unsavory plans for the future of Skyrim.  The Stormcloaks are nationalists who believe that Skyrim should be put in the hands of the Nords and should kick out all the lesser races.  The Civil War questline is exceptionally childish in my opinion, an attempt to create a political situation with depth and pathos by insuring that the player will not root for any side and ultimately determine who is the least awful for Skyrim basically off a coin flip (it is, unfortunately, the Imperials as they are the relatively less racist ones).

But I want to draw your attention to the battle cry for the Stormcloak rebellion.  "Skyrim is for the Nords".  Racism is incredibly central to the Stormcloaks, it is not simply a byproduct of their nationalist tendencies.  It's a feature.  So what does that say about the fact that the player can choose to become part of this rebellion.  The Stormcloaks are not, explicitly, the villains in Skyrim, they are a faction that the player can choose to become involved with and aid in their "reclamation" of Skyrim.  And given that the Stormcloaks are so heavily racist and centered around the nationalist belief that Skyrim should belong solely to the people who are "native born", there is only one conclusion you can draw from this: Skyrim wants you to play as a Nord.

The entire Civil War storyline, the second most important questline in Skyrim outside of the main one, just does not make justifiable sense unless you are playing as a Nord.  No other race in Skyrim has any reason to ever side with the Stormcloaks, they are motivated by the idea that your race is inferior to the Nords and should be kicked out of Skyrim.  The only reason Ulfric even likes you, no matter what race you end up being, is because you are the Dragonborn, he sees you as kin.  I mean actually the reason is that Ulfric meets the player before they even create their character and as such forms a kinship with them as mutual prisoners heading to an execution and it would frankly be weird for him to then be super racist to you after already treating you as a brother but I digress.  Skyrim is, yet again, pushing the player into a box despite promising them freedom.

Skyrim pushing you to be a Nord and building a massive chunk of the game off characters being unambiguously racist to people who aren't Nords is not simply a role-playing issue, however.  Nords, as a race, are naturally suited to being warriors.  They excel at Two-handed skills and have natural boons in Smithing, Block, Light Armor, One-handed, and Speech.  They are perfect for either being a warrior or a warrior-rogue dual class, but honestly it's more just "warrior" because the rogue skills they excel in are more generic and arguably more useful for warriors anyways.  The game has, either accidentally or intentionally, placed a lot of emphasis on leaning into warrior.  Its systems, worldbuilding, and quest structure have all compounded into a system where, if the player is just to intuit what they should do by what the game is communicating to them, they will inevitably become a Nord Warrior, or otherwise have no reason to even engage with some of the core ideas at the center of one of Skyrim's most central questlines.

This emphasis on the warrior class feeds back into the Guild problem.  I mentioned in the guild section that two of the guilds are pretty out of the way and, if you are intuitively following the main quest to determine where you go and what you do, you are unlikely to find them.  The Thieves' Guild is in a city you go to pretty late in the main quest and, while you are almost immediately involved in the Guild's storyline once you enter the city the Guild is found in, by the time you encounter the Thieves Guild you are very likely to have decided on your build and may not even be a thief even a little.  The College of Winterhold, meanwhile, is something you will never encounter even when the quest takes you to Winterhold, because the quest has you speaking with the "Jarl" of Winterhold, essentially the governor, and his house is the first place in Winterhold.  You could go the entire game without encountering the Mages' guild.

Now, I think this is just bad open world RPG design on its face?  Ideally an open world RPG would, through its main questline, nudge the player in the direction of all the key points it wants to make within its first "Act".  By the following the main quest, you should be able to naturally encounter all of the key points and run into any interesting cities, quests, or interesting areas that you can then go "I want to do this, I want to explore this part of the game more".  That way a player who is playing the game for the first time can organically find things like the factions of the Civil War storyline, the guilds, or just interesting geography.  And then when you inevitably start the game all over again because you realize its first like 20 hours are better than any other part of the game, you can use that knowledge to be more direct on how you explore Skyrim.  Ironically, for a game that wants you to intuit a very particular play pattern, Skyrim doesn't want you to organically find the cool stuff in the game.

But I want to talk about the third guild, the warriors guild.  The Companions.  Unlike the other guilds in Skyrim, the Companions are not even remotely out of the way.  They are centrally located, their guild hall is within the first major city you will go into if you are following the main storyline, which is also the "main hub" for basically the entire game.  They are an instance of the game nudging you into finding the significant stuff, you will naturally encounter this guild not just by playing the game but very early on in the game's "main story", You will very likely encounter the Companions within the first five hours of playing, as all you need to be pointed in the direction of Whiterun is to complete the tutorial, be pointed to your first dungeon, and then get the note that you should ask about the weird things happening to you at Whiterun.  More than that, though, the game actively introduces you to the Companions if you are following the "intended path", having the guild slaying a giant in the farmland on the outskirts of Whiterun.  The fact that they make the Companions so central, to the point where the player could easily find them and want to join them within the first hours of the game, continues to put emphasis on the warrior class.  And while the Companions as a guild are ultimately apolitical, they will side with Ulfric Stormcloak in the Civil War if left to their own devices, once again putting emphasis on the Nord Warrior build.

Dungeons and Dragons

I want you to really quickly take the selection of "Thief" skills into account.  The rough umbrella of thief skills includes six very specific skills: sneak, pickpocketing, speech, lockpicking, light armor, and alchemy.  Six very distinctive abilities that imply a certain play style.  The thief wants to find clever, non-violent ways of solving problems.  Either persuading their targets to their side, intimidating their targets, stealing from them, planting things on them, poisoning them, that sort of thing.  It is a play style that is very in-line with how a thief would play, you are expected to find more sneaky and creative ways of solving a problem than just "hitting it until it dies".  The thieves don't even naturally have any combat skills, with their only skill tree that gives them actual combat abilities being the Stealth tree and them having to share their one actual weapon skill, archery, with Warriors (it's even officially considered under the Warrior umbrella, officially).  So it would be a shame if, hypothetically, the majority of gameplay in Skyrim is entirely combat focused with very few opportunities to utilize your thief skillsets.

The vast majority of Skyrim's actual gameplay is, indeed, spent in combat.  In particular, it is spent in dungeons.  Lots and lots of dungeons.  Old crypts, caves, mines, that sort of thing.  No matter what the questline is or what objective you are ultimately hoping to accomplish, you are very likely to end up in a very similar looking scenario.  Making your way through narrow underground corridors fighting off anywhere between 5 and 15 enemies.  In particular, two types of enemies: the undead draugr and the living bandits.  Other common enemy types you'll fight include the native fauna of Skyrim, magical beasts like trolls, and unambiguously evil people conducting rituals in dingy caves for their own goals.  In other words, the vast majority of Skyrim's gameplay is spent engaging in encounters with enemies for whom you have no choice but to fight.

Now, I am not going to sit here and pretend like this isn't an inevitability.  It's an RPG, you gotta fight from time to time.  And it is unreasonable to state that it's some sort of inherent flaw that one of the three classes of Skyrim lacks combat abilities if you build them "pure".  Nobody would ever build them pure, you gaining skills in more combat-able skills like one-handed is an inevitability.  Even if you max out your Sneak so stealth kills come easy to you, you will inevitably upgrade either your one-handed or your archery just by virtue of attacking with those weapons to perform the stealth kills.  It would be ludicrous to assume the game is telling you that the way to play rogue in this game is to never fight.  However, I do think it's noteworthy that the game put this set of skills under the same umbrella because it is implying more interesting and creative solutions than it will ultimately deliver on.

Take for instance one of the most central skills in the Thief umbrella: Speech.  The fact that your ability to communicate is, in itself, a skill inherent to the game design implies a very specific outcome: you will be able to talk your way into or out of situations.  It implies that more interesting solutions are available to the player if they choose to engage with certain parts of the game.  That you may be able to avoid doing long, tedious dungeons by simply being persuasive enough to talk a character into handing over what you need them to.  But said checks are very few and far between, with most characters not having a single opportunity to persuade them at all in their travels.  And, as the vast majority of the content in the game is sequestered into dungeons with hostile mobs who can't or won't be reasoned with, your Speech skill does nothing for you for the bulk of gameplay.

Bandits and Necromancers aren't exactly interested in diplomacy and even if you were to calm them down somehow, you would not be able to have a meaningful discussion with them to hash it out.  They will simply become hostile again once the calming power ends.  Your inability to really use Speech to accomplish anything only ends up making the skill an active detriment, as its primary purpose ends up being to give the player better deals for buying and selling in Skyrim but due to how Skyrim's economy works, the more you can sell things for, the less you'll be able to sell.  I've seen maxed out Speech players having to travel around the entire land of Skyrim to unload treasure they've gotten from their ventures, only to ultimately sell a fraction of it.

This heavy focus on combat also manifests in the near constant threat of dragon attacks.  Dragons are, frankly, a complete and total nuisance in Skyrim.  What at first seems to be a powerful foe that will appear at key story moments quickly becomes essentially an overgrown rat that will show up at any point to bug you.  Dragons are so common in Skyrim that the player is likely to become completely desensitized to fighting them and honestly ignore their presence entirely as the gains you get from them become less and less fruitful as the game goes on.  Their ability to show up at the most inopportune times causes dragons to turn even a brisk stroll in a field into a boss encounter.  And the thing about bosses is that you have to fight them if you want them to leave you alone.  Dragons, more than any other enemy type, want you dead specifically.  It is their singular goal in life.  The Dovakiin is literally the only one that can stop the reign of fire from returning.  So you gotta fight them.

Dragons are also some of the worst enemies to fight in the game if you are doing anything other than traditional weaponry.  For starters, Dragons tend to stay high up in the air until enough damage has been done to them to ground them.  This is, already, a non-starter for the majority of builds in the game.  Magic has a very limited range which often makes it so that you can only hope to damage these beasts as they swoop down, and really the only weapon to have the range to assist you are bows.  Hopefully, if you're fighting dragons, you'll be near enough to a population center to enlist the aid of other people to do that part for you.  But if you're, I don't know, exploring.  In this open world RPG.  You are probably on your own and having to simply hope that you have an hour to deal with it if you didn't pick Archery as part of your build.  But even if you do ground them, dragons are very resilient to most of the combat types in the game.  They are incredibly unreliable in fighting them and, frankly, the types that are good against this very common threat are the Warrior types.  Swords, axes, warhammers and bows.  These work far better than any other combat skill you can have in the game.

When you look at how everything in Skyrim intersects, a picture is painted on what the problems with Skyrim actually are.  Skyrim claims to want to give the player a lot of freedom on how they build their own character.  How they want them to engage with the game on a role-playing perspective.  Be a High Elf mage who charms his way through every conversation.  Be a Nord Thief who solves every problem with violence.  Be a Khajit and have every character you meet instantly assume that you have a drug addiction, including the other Khajit.  The world is your oyster.  However, it seems to be untrue.  Skyrim seems very restrictive.  It uses its storytelling, game design and just general adherence to fantasy RPG tropes to try and railroad you into a very specific play style.  It wants to influence your build, and then also influence how that build grows, and then influence what you do with that build, and then influence where the story goes because of how you chose to start, and then ultimately tell you if you chose to build your character in any way that isn't heavily focused on combat, it sucks to suck.  I have often said that RPGs are about choice and consequence.  That you as the player make choices and have to work within the consequences of those choices.  But Skyrim seems like it is all consequence.  You either choose the most sensible build at character creation to engage with the grander game or just have a categorically worse gaming experience.  And the thing about all this is that none of it is true.

Too Much Player Freedom

Skyrim's problem is not that it railroads too much.  I have framed Skyrim under these arguments because I want you to understand how much Skyrim seems to imply consequence.  That it wants you to believe that there are serious ramifications to the decisions you make.  That it does matter what you choose to do, matters extremely.  Almost matters to the point that Skyrim is tell you that it has a specific way of play in mind and that your freedom is clashing against it.  And I wanted you to see this because I want you to be aware of how it does not, in fact, matter in the slightest.  Skyrim does not have any consequences for anything you do.  Because that would be asking the player to live with their choices.  And Skyrim doesn't believe in that.

Take, for instance, the guilds.  The fact that there are guilds at all implies that the game wants to reward you for choosing specific paths.  You are, in a sense, giving each "class" exclusive content that is only available to them.  And yes, that means that not every build would be able to access said content, but that's the consequence for your choices.  The whole point of having a class and guild system is to highlight the uniqueness of each class.  Is is actually good RPG design to make a player unable to access the content within the guilds they are not prepared to join, it is a choice they made that leads to a consequence that helps inform their character.  It is a role.  You are expected to play.  In a role-playing game.

But Skyrim hates the idea of any content in the game, any content at all, being unavailable.  It wants the player to be able to do everything, to have access to all the content available to them on a singular playthrough.  And the guilds being such significant questlines are the biggest examples of this.  The guilds are not exclusionary, the Dragonborn can join any of them at any time and begin their specific questlines.  Skyrim does this because Skyrim believes very strongly in the idea that they put cool content into the game and as such they don't want players missing out on said content.  So, despite the guilds being very class/build specific in theory, the actual checks to join them are minor.

To be accepted into the Companion's, your only real requirement is to win a singular swordfight against a moderately difficult opponent.  To join the College of Winterhold, you only have to cast a tier 2 spell once, something that is less about your spellcasting abilities and more about your ability to level up your Mana as there are no restrictions put on learning spells based on how much you level up those skills.  And to join the Thieves' Guild, you simply need to lockpick a couple locks, which you are probably more than capable of as Lockpicking is one of the most universally important skills in the game, and then pass a Pickpocketing check which isn't very difficult to pass but even if you miss it, you can just like.  Reload and do it again.  These are all things you can do without needing to invest practically anything into their relevant skills, with the most difficult of these checks only needing you to brute force a couple levels into MP in order to pass it.  And after that point, you never have to do any of this again.  You never have to swing a sword, cast a spell, or steal from someone again.  You can move through the entire rest of the game never having to contend with the consequences of the play style and build you've crafted.

This decision to allow the player to have very little standing in their way to joining all three guilds regardless of whether or not they fit into them has the side issue of making a mockery of the guilds.  Skyrim is a power fantasy narrative.  The player character is a special chosen one who is uniquely suited to saving the world and everyone is ultimately reliant on and respectful of them.  But, this status does not simply apply to the main quest.  In basically every quest line, the ultimate conclusion is that the Dragonborn ends up taking on a very significant role within the party involved in said questline.  I don't like this decision in the first place.  I actually find it pretty exhausting when a main character is the most important character in the story across the board just because they are important in one specific instance.  It makes the world feel weaker to me, that any history it has and any character relationships that were formed are secondary to making the player feel like they're the coolest guy to ever exist.

The Companions are a group of Warriors that have been fighting together for a long time, some of the permanent companions (i.e., not adventurers or mercenaries who use the guild for a meal and a place to rest their head on their travels) have been fighting together their whole lives.  This is a family who has history and interpersonal relationships.  And within a matter of days they've decided you have the right to be in charge of the whole operation.  The College of Winterhold is a school.  A place of learning.  It has teachers to be concerned with, tuition to collect.  It needs a headmaster that is equipped to understand its function as a place of education.  And the Dragonborn can show up off the street, attend two classes and then through a series of events become the new headmaster of the College.  The only one of these questlines that makes any amount of sense is the Thieves Guild.  They're a mob.  They're loyal to whomever proves themselves to be the strongest in the room.  They think that person will lead them better than the previous guy, especially when the previous guy tried to become a god.  But even then the Thieves Guild has people who are better suited for succession.  Long time thieves that know the business and can bring the Guild into a better tomorrow.  And instead, they choose you, a homeless drifter who wandered into the city on accident because they saw an attractive lady and found out this was where they could do something about that.

Skyrim cares so little about its world and its characters that it is willing to balk everything about them to make the player feel like they're the center of the universe.  It makes the quests feel superficial, the characters hollow, the world lesser.  But, because Skyrim wants to insure that every option is available to the player, these quests are actively made a mockery of.  The person who swung a sword a few times in a single fight 20 minutes after joining the Warrior's guild and then spent the entire rest of the game casting magic is now the head of the Companions.  The person who casted one spell and went to one class where they didn't need to participate, only to then brute force the rest of the way through the questline with a bow is now the headmaster of the Mage's college.  The person who struggled to plant a stolen item onto another person because their Sneak skill was barely leveled up and then clanked around with their warhammer and heavy armor is now the head of the Thieves Guild.  It is farce.  In Skyrim you play the role of a jester, and the world of this groundbreaking RPG with literal books upon books of lore is the joke.

You remember how I said Ulfric Stormcloak's primary motivation in this game was racism?  But that ultimately he refuses to be racist to the Dragonborn?  That was actually foreshadowing.  So, Bethesda clearly did not want to have to contend with the idea that Ulfric Stormcloak, a man so racist and so nationalist that his campaign to reclaim a world he believes is rightfully his is literally led by a rallying cry about who Skyrim rightfully belongs to, would have those same racist views towards the Dragonborn if they chose to play a race other than the Nords.  You meet Ulfric before the character creator and, at that time, he already considers you a friend.  Two prisoners marching towards the gallows.  When your dragon blood is revealed, Ulfrig begins to see you as kin, as he himself is one of the last descendants of the dragons.  So, of course, why would he be racist towards you?  He sees you differently from all the other people he wants to kick out of Skyrim if he's put in charge.

However, I think this creates a much bigger issue with the Stormcloak rebellion: it is, ultimately, toothless.  That despite grandiose claims of wanting to usher in a new age of Skyrim where the Nords once again reign supreme, there is little to it besides posturing.  The Stormcloaks are only a racist, nationalist movement insofar as it is convenient to the game for them to be.  It's all posturing with little substance.  Now don't get me wrong, I'm glad their racist ideology ultimately amounts to nothing.  I think the simple fact that they built a very significant questline around the idea of "do you or do you not" support racism is concerning.  Like, I guess it can be interesting from a role-playing perspective, but I will squint at you if you looked at the Stormcloaks and went "yeah, those are my guys".  At the same time, though, you would expect a group whose belief in Nord supremacy is so strong that it's literally their battle cry to begin enacting their political ideologies if you helped put them in charge of Skyrim.

But they don't.  The lack of racism that is felt from their interactions with the player character is the same lack of racism felt when they take over Skyrim.  They are frustratingly apolitical, in a way that makes it feel like you have done literally nothing to change Skyrim.  Granted, there's kind of a political commentary to that fact that especially when Skyrim came out, would've probably been resonant with the people.  Politicians promising big things on their campaign trails only to do nothing in office is a very common problem in the world and, especially, for America where Skyrim was produced.  However, this makes the ending to the Civil War questline, again one of the most central questlines in Skyrim second only to the main quest itself, very unsatisfactory.  You are making massive choices, choices that would reshape the country on a fundamental level, and what comes out of it?  Nothing.  Nothing at all.

To enact the ideologies that Ulfric Stormcloak represents would, after all, mean a fundamental shift in how Skyrim operates.  It would mean sewing distrust between the Dragonborn and the non-Nordic people of the country.  It would mean changing NPC behavior, dialog, storylines in a very lode-bearing way.  And, most importantly, it would mean making quests exclusionary.  The other races of Skyrim would not exactly enjoy living under a regime that wants to tear them from homes, nor aiding the person who abetted their conquest.  It would mean making quests either more difficult to gain, or removing them from your available pool entirely.  If the orc city in Skyrim was under a regime that hated orcs, they wouldn't exactly be happy about the person who let that regime sit on the throne.  If the Khajit are run out of Skyrim because everyone thinks they're inherently untrustworthy thieves then they certainly won't be around to help the player when they're on the road and need to unload junk.

Choosing to side with Ulfric Stormcloak would require massive consequences that would fundamentally reshape the world of Skyrim.  But Skyrim doesn't want you to ever face the consequences of your decisions.  And so the only tangible changes that happen as a result of choosing a side in the Civil War is that certain NPCs will be different, as their sympathies were to one side of the war or the other, and the majority of the guards in the game will either wear Imperial brown or Stormcloak blue.  The political situation of an entire country reduced down to a palette change.  That's Skyrim for you, I guess.

The heavy focus on combat also does not matter for the very reason that this game is so potentially interesting from a character building standpoint: the Skills.  I like the Skill system, I really do.  In theory it allows for a lot of experimentation with your character, allows them to be a super unique build all your own.  The problem is, as you would probably imagine given everything else, that Skyrim does not believe in creating a system with boundaries.  Investing heavily into a skill never actually dictates permanently what your play style is, if you invest heavily into magic and then decide after 50 hours of playing you want to be a traditional warrior, the game just allows you to do that.  It's even beneficial to do that, as skills level up much faster when they start, so if anything the game encourages you to invest in a skill for as long as it takes to get whatever you want out of it and then hard pivot when the returns start slowing down.  After all, leveling up skills is important for just leveling up in general.  You get experience the normal way you would in an RPG in Skyrim, defeating enemies and completing sidequests, but the fastest way to propel yourself to a level up is to level up your skills.  So when you're 60 hours in and you're starting to slow down on your level ups, you can just start leveling up the lesser skills and getting big EXP pockets.

So when you inevitably realize after playing for 30 hours that the skills you've been investing in this entire time because you wanted to role-play as a crafty rogue that uses illusions and potions to get what they want are completely useless for the vast majority of this game, it is exceptionally easy to just pivot into what the game wants you to do.  This is even a joke within the Skyrim community, the idea of "I want to do a unique build for this next run" only to always end up either as a dual-wielding warrior or a stealth archer.  It is, of course, not good criticism to criticize a game for players finding an optimal path to do things.  Players will always optimize the fun out of a video game and to behave as if the game is bad because they do so is bad criticism.  But I think the problem with Skyrim is that the optimal build is the build the game is naturally designed to lead you into.  Its storytelling, gameplay, and core game design all benefit a warrior build, one that favors combat skills like archery and swords.  And because it doesn't want the player to ever be inconvenienced by the choices they make, it offers you the ability to change into the optimal build at any moment that is convenient for the player.

Or, at least, that's mostly true.  Skyrim does have one key restriction on the skill system that, hypothetically, keeps the player honest.  Skill points.  You get a skill point upon each level up and these skill points are used to unlock the perks in each given skill tree.  As stated earlier on, these perks are often very lode-bearing, certain skills are simply wholly ineffectual without their perks to work with.  And Skyrim has a level cap.  You will, eventually, be unable to gain more skill points and as such have to be particular about how you try to rework your build.  Now, this is not a perfect solution for Skyrim's various problems, you will have more skill points than you know what to do with in any given run and will have enough to max out many of the game's skill trees.  But it is a limitation set by the game that keeps the player from just fully reworking their build like 9 times across the journey.  You will, eventually, be out of skill points and as such can only really afford to make significant pivots in play style sparingly.

At least until the DLC extended the level cap so you could get enough skill points to max out every skill tree so there's no reason to live with your choices ever.  This is a very common way that DLC rewards players, mind you, it's not a Skyrim specific problem.  A lot of games are designed around a skill tree where you are forced to make choices, as you will not have enough skill points to fully fill out the skill tree in the base game.  I think about Horizon: Zero Dawn, for instance, whose level cap makes it so you will naturally miss out on skills and have to curate your build to your play style, only to then introduce a DLC where you increase the level cap enough to max out the skill tree.  And this is fine.  I think that having this as a reward for the players who love your game enough to put the most time they can into it, including purchasing an entire separate campaign, is good.  The problem is that this isn't a reward as soon as the DLC has had time to be out for a while, it becomes part of the game.

Unless you have tracked down an original copy of Skyrim for the Xbox 360 or PlayStation 3, you have never played a version of Skyrim with a restrictive level cap.  From the game's very first rerelease to the modern day, every version of Skyrim released has had the DLC for the game baked into the base game.  This creates a number of issues, namely the inelegant way that Skyrim handles its DLC where it demands you address it or it'll just start killing any non-essential NPCs.  But it also means that there is never a restriction put in place by the game to stop you from being everything.  It'll be an uphill climb, don't get me wrong, maxing out every skill without cheating is certainly not an easy thing to do.  But this also means that you can do whatever you want without consequence.  Inevitably, you will gain the ability to pivot in whatever way you want.  There is no reason not to do as much as you possibly can.  Learn every skill.

It's almost poetic in a way, isn't it.  The one singular restriction that Skyrim had put on your ability to do everything, the one thing to keep you honest with how you built your character, and it is seen as little more than a problem to be fixed in a later update.  Don't worry about having to utilize the skills you've invested all your time into to make your way into the end of the game.  Even if you are 100 hours in to this playthrough, you can just simply pick up a bow and start shooting and eventually the idea that you were ever anything but a stealth archer will be something that neither you nor the game cares about or remembers.  The game removing the only built-in consequence to your actions.  You have every choice.  You have no consequences for any of them.  The world is your sandbox.

And, indeed, that is how people enjoy Skyrim.  As a sandbox.  A game that puts no restrictions on where you can go and what you can do.  A game where you can just be.  If you want to do every quest?  Go for it.  You want to live out the ultimate power fantasy in a world that exists to please you and you alone?  You got it dude!  You want to go on a mass-murdering spree, killing every single NPC you possibly can and then managing to get away with it because you managed to convince the guards not to kill you and instead arrest you, at which point you broke out of prison no harm no foul?  You know you can do that.  Skyrim is fun.  It is a complete and total power fantasy, a game where you can just mess around and never have to deal with the consequences.  I have been caught up in it myself, I have had loads of fun with Skyrim.  It scratches a very specific itch, the kind that games like Grand Theft Auto scratch.  But in a setting that is arguably more interesting, this serious dark fantasy with a long running history.

Skyrim is a freeing experience, a game with no borders, no railroading, no consequences.  But RPGs are consequences.  RPGs are about a player deciding what they want to be and then having to deal with the fallout of those decisions.  The player is allowed to do everything without ramification on doing anything.  It is a sandbox.  And the thing about sandboxes are that they are full of sand.  There is nothing to them on their own, it is entirely what the person playing in them brings to the sandbox.  Skyrim is not allowed to feel like a living world with real characters who have relationships and bonds because Skyrim only exists for what the player wants to do it.  It becomes hollow, superficial.  A setting for play rather than a world to be experienced.  It is little more than a Castle Greyskull playset masquerading as high fantasy fiction.  Many people love Skyrim.  And I understand why.  It's fun to play in a sandbox.  But Skyrim isn't meant to be a sandbox.  Skyrim is an RPG.  It's supposed to be a place where your actions have consequences and your choices matter.  But if every action only benefits and every choice can be undone, then what remains?  What is Skyrim beyond a toy?  For me personally, it's a question that only has one answer.  Skyrim is a bad RPG.

Thursday, November 5, 2026

There Shouldn't Be An Official Mother 4

 I love the Mother series.  Though I am unfortunately not cool enough to have gotten onboard with it during the Golden Age of the Mother fandom, I have been a Mother fan for a lot of my life.  When I was first getting online back in 2006/2007, I was kind of obsessed with retro games and it wasn't long before I was pointed in the direction of Earthbound, the at the time incredibly obscure SNES masterpiece.  I've told this story a million times before but when I was a teenager, I was looking for videos on Super Mario RPG because I was into Mario and had just found out that RPGs were a genre that I loved and finding out that there was a marriage of the two blew my mind.  So I was looking for info and I stumbled upon a YouTuber, who at the time was pretty well known for playing older Nintendo RPGs.  And, in wanting to sort of watch all the content on his channel, I discovered Earthbound.

Earthbound would then become one of my favorite games of all time, a game I fell in love with hard and fast.  The fact it was so unique compared to anything I had experienced, an RPG set in modern day America and dealing with modern problems in a satirical way hooked me.  Even when I was young and less media literate, I knew this was something truly special.  It's a game I've played partially or in full many times over the years and it's one I can keep coming back to infinitely.  And I've had the pleasure of not just making many friends over Earthbound but being able to see so many of my own friends get on board with it.  Guiding them with a subtle hand and a lotta snark about their playing.  It's been foundational for me.

Unfortunately, until I started this era of game clearing, I never really had room for either the prequel or sequel.  I had started both Earthbound Beginnings and Mother 3 at various points in the past, I had bought Beginnings excitedly when it was announced for the WiiU Virtual Console and had chipped away at the first bits of Mother 3 numerous times in the past.  But the archaic design of Beginnings and the fact that Mother 3 never got an official English release always made me stop playing them.  I used to be such a good boy who would never consider emulating anything so Mother 3 was always like "well, maybe I shouldn't be doing this".  But I have completed all three games now and doing so has given me a deeper understanding of what Mother is.  What this series is attempting to accomplish, how these three fairly dissonant pieces are actually connected.  And moreover, it has led me to a conclusion:

There Shouldn't Be A(n Official) Mother 4

The Trilogy

For starters, I just want to cover the three games individually.  I think to set-up what I am attempting to say, I need to sort of synopsize the three games on a game-by-game level.  I will be doing so in the order that I personally played the three games first, which I'm obviously biased towards since it's how I did it but I also think that, thematically, the games are strongest when you do it this way.  Oh and spoilers, obviously, if you care.  As such we will be starting with...

Earthbound/Mother 2

I am Earthbound.  I'm an RPG.  The second game in a set of three.  Didn't do so hot when I first debuted, but 20 years later I got attitude.  Shoutouts to Stephen Georg.  If there is a game in this trilogy which the average person is familiar with, it is the middle entry, Earthbound.  Released in 1994 in Japan and 1995 in America, Earthbound has become one of the most famous "cult classics" in video gaming and arguably the greatest of the Super Nintendo era of RPGs.  To this day Earthbound remains noteworthy for its interesting style and tone, its divorcing of itself from the fantasy trappings of the RPG genre and its social commentary and satire.  It remains one of the most beloved video games of all time and is largely considered a must-play of the JRPG genre, which is very impressive because it seems so unassuming.  It has a very simple art style and was a very traditional turn-based RPG at a time when ATB was starting to overtake the genre.  Compared to its contemporaries (Chrono Trigger, Final Fantasy VI, Super Mario RPG), it definitely doesn't look that noteworthy by comparison.  But, it's like the song linked above said, Earthbound fans are coming through your front door, because 30,000 signatures are hard to ignore.  That was very big for an online petition back in the day, trust me.

Set in the 1990s, Earthbound starts in the small town of Onett on the continent of Eagleland.  One night, a meteorite crashes into a hillside in the woods surrounding Onett, awakening the entire town.  One such resident awoken by the crash was Ness, a young boy who lives just on the outskirts of Onett with his mother and sister.  Ness decides to go investigate the crash, before being blocked by a police barricade and his next door neighbor, friend, and bully Pokey Minch.  Pokey assures Ness that he has everything handled and that Ness should just go home and go back to sleep.  Later that night, after the police have left, Ness is awoken by Pokey who is in a panic.  His younger brother, Picky, had snuck out to investigate crash at some point during the night and if Pokey doesn't come home with him, it'll be punishment for him.  This normally would not be a problem, but the local fauna in Onett, stray dogs, crows and snakes, are behaving strangely since the meteor crashed down.  Ness, being a kindhearted boy, decides to help Pokey.  Taking his dog with him for extra protection, Ness and gang set out to finally view the meteor crash site and hopefully find Pokey's little brother.

What the trio finds at the top of the hill is not just a meteorite, nor is it just Pokey's little brother.  A light emanates from the crashed space rock, revealing it is not truly a rock at all, but rather a ship that has crash landed with only a single being inside.  This is Buzz Buzz, a being from ten years in the future who has transformed themselves into a beetle to survive the time traveling process, and tells Ness his tragic tale.  In the time Buzz Buzz comes from, the world has been invaded by a being known as Giygas, an entity of ultimate evil who corrupts the minds of man to make them their most evil selves.  Giygas then quickly discovered that he was destined to be defeated by a group of four chosen heroes, Ness and three friends he will have met across his life.  Not wanting to be defeated, Giygas concocts a new plan: he will send his invasion forces back in time to corrupt the world of Ness' childhood, thereby preventing him from ever growing up to be the hero who will stop him.  He sends monsters to infect the areas Ness must go to in order to be in tune with his power and works to influence the adults in this time to become mean, greedy, and corrupt.  Fortunately, Buzz Buzz was able to travel back in time to tell Ness of this plan before Giygas could intercept Ness as a child and potentially take him off the board entirely.  Unfortunately, the powerful bug, being a bug, ends up getting squashed early on in their adventure, leaving Ness to find his future compatriots and free his Sanctuaries scattered across the world in order to prevent Giygas from taking over the world in his time.

After freeing the first Sanctuary location from Giygas' hold, Ness arrives in Twoson and begins seeing the full extent of Giygas' influence.  I just want to make sure y'all are aware that the cops in Onett didn't assault a child because they were under Giygas' influence, they did that because they're cops.  People walk the streets, angry, drunk, New Age AND Retro somehow.  Most notably, one of Ness' future compatriots, a "friend he hasn't met yet", Paula Polestar, has gone missing.  This disappearance seems connected to the Happy Happy cult who lives in a commune in the Valley to the east of Twoson, and indeed when Ness goes to investigate the cult, he finds Paula imprisoned in a cabin owned by the cult's leader, Mr. Carpainter.  Carpainter worships a mysterious golden statue known as the Mani Mani, the symbol of Giygas' influence in the world.  Also, somehow, Pokey Minch has arrived in the Happy Happy Village, and he has become a high ranking member of the cult.  Even being the one charged with keeping watch over Paula's jail cell.  Upon Ness' appearance and subsequent defeat of Carpainter though, he runs away to the big city.  Now joined by Paula, Ness finds another Sanctuary and moves on to fight Giygas' influence over the world.

Joined by their third friend, Jeff, in Threed, the trio makes their way to the Metropolis of Fourside.  This big city has been fully corrupted by Giygas' influence, with their Mayor, Mr. Monotoli, turning the place into a monument of greed and corruption.  The kind of place where everyone is bought and if you're not bought, you're about to be arrested.  Wouldn't you know it, Pokey is here too, having set himself up as Monotoli's right hand man.  Interesting that, Pokey seems to follow the exact trail of Giygas' influence to set himself up.  It's almost as if this game is saying something about the nature of the capitalist idea of "upward mobility".  Funny that.  Anyways, Monotoli, under the influence of Giygas, makes what is one of the entities biggest moves.  He kidnaps Paula and attempts to imprison Ness and Jeff in the realm of Moonside, a seemingly backwards world where the evil of Giygas emanates from, the world itself seemingly birthed from a Mani Mani statue.  The venture fails, and the duo breaks the Mani Mani statue and rescues Paula.  In the chaos, however, Pokey escapes yet again.

The group continues their journey, eventually being joined by their fourth friend, Poo, and traveling to the farthest reaches of the world to find Ness' Sanctuaries.  After collecting all 8 and unlocking Ness' true power by defeating the fear inside of him, we set out to defeat Giygas once and for all.  The group quickly discovers, however, that Giygas is not in this time.  In fact, Giygas has retreated to the very beginning of time itself, where he sits amassing loathing and hatred to become the ultimate evil.  The group finds a way to travel to where he is, but there is an issue.  Organic matter cannot sustain long term time travel.  For the gang to complete their mission, they must put themselves in robotic bodies.  And there's no guarantee they will ever be able to return, defeating Giygas might strand them at the beginning of time never to return to their bodies.  After a short deliberation, the quartet decides that saving the world is more important than what happens to them, and so they undergo the transference.  And then they set out to defeat Giygas once and for all.

When they arrive at Giygas' hiding place, a figure arrives in a small spiderlike mech, a figure who has become corrupted by Giygas' influence, who now serves as his righthand, who practically worships him.  This figure is, of course, Pokey Minch.  Pokey taunts Ness and the gang, saying that their weak heroics are no match for the sheer might of his master.  Giygas is less a being at this point, after all, and more an all consuming, oppressive hatred.  An entity whose ability to think and act rationally is really due to the machine containing him moreso than his nature at this point.  Giygas is so powerful at this point that the very nature of its assault is impossible to conceptualize.  And, indeed, when the machine containing it is broken, what is unleashed is an omnipotent, universe warping entity of primal hatred, one who both seeks Ness' destruction and is desperate to hold onto the boy as a tether to the intelligent being he once was.  All hope truly seems lost, the gang fighting and fighting and fighting but unable to put a dent in the sheer reality warping hatred of Giygas.

But as all hope seems lost, Paula puts out a plea into the void.  A plea for anyone who might be listening, a plea for those beyond Giygas' infinity to come to their aid.  Slowly but surely, the plea reaches across space and time to everyone that the gang had met along their journey.  All the friends they made along the way, their family, the people they aided, they all hear Paula's plea.  And every one of them unites in sending Ness and the gang their love.  Giygas is unable to stand the sheer, overwhelming might of such pure love, the overwhelming power of this connection.  And so he begins to weaken.  Begins to recede.  His hatred continues to get smaller and smaller until Giygas is nothing.  Pokey, being good at running away, once again flees as the fortress at the beginning of time starts to collapse without Giygas there to sustain it.  And for a brief moment, it appears our heroes have won at great cost, their robotic forms laying dead in a destroyed palace of hatred.  But the universe is not yet done with them.  Their souls fly out of their robotic facsimiles and back into their bodies across space and time, awakening back in the 1990s moments after they had left.

With that, the world is at peace.  All the monsters have disappeared, all the evidence of Giygas' reign of terror have gone as if they had never existed in the first place.  Poo and Jeff return to their lives and Ness walks Paula home, the two unable to say the things they feel about each other and instead just vow to keep in contact (although the ending makes it ambiguous on whether or not that happens, as the game seemingly ends with Ness looking over the memories of his adventure and going "I miss you").  Everything seems to go back to normal.  Until one night, Ness awakens to the sound of pounding on his door, akin to the very thing that started his journey in the first place.  When he goes to answer it, Picky Minch stumbles in, saying that his family had received a letter from Pokey in the middle of the night.  It just appeared in their mailbox.  Pokey had managed to somehow escape from the end of time, and he vows to return another day.  And so Earthbound ends, with a promise of a future that it would not receive for quite some time.  Which brings us to...

Mother 3

Mother 3 is just as famous as its predecessor, if not moreso.  Teased during Earthbound and eventually announced for the Nintendo 64 in the late 1990s, Mother 3 had what was, at the time, an unusually long development cycle.  Changing consoles multiple times and art styles/gameplay with it, eventually Mother 3 would be released at the end of the life cycle of Nintendo's Game Boy Advance system.  Being in a niche genre, releasing at the end of a console's lifespan, and with Itoi's usual "devil may care" attitude toward things like copyright or themes that may be inappropriate for certain audiences overseas, Nintendo ultimately made the decision not to localize Mother 3 outside of Japan.  This decision would end up turning Mother 3 into a symbol for games only released in one single territory despite large fanbases globally.  The campaign to petition Nintendo for a localization was one of the first prominent grassroots online fan campaigns, and would pave the way for things like Operation Rainfall and Operation Moonfall in the subsequent years.  And its now famous fan translation, done by the wonderful people at Earthbound fan site and secret dating platform Starmen.net has become the emblem for fan localizations/patches.

Set in an unknown time on an island in the middle of Nowhere, Mother 3 primarily tells the story of Lucas, a young boy who grew up in the rural farming village of Tazmily.  The game shifts perspectives several times across its playtime but Lucas is both the protagonist that you start the game on, being the playable character of the game's prologue, but also is the protagonist for pretty much the entirety of the game's second half.  I hope you will forgive me for kind of glancing over the first half, Mother 3 is genuinely a very brilliant game but there is a very specific point I'm trying to make here and it's best served to start at Chapter 4 and sort of fill-in the blanks as needed.  If you want to know more about Mother 3, please read my blog post about it, I cover like everything in-depth~

Lucas' story begins several years after the first three chapters of the game.  After losing his mother and twin brother when he was very young and watching his hometown turn from a idyllic paradise to a capitalist hellscape due to one guy with very good marketing showing up into town, Lucas has been waiting for word on where his friend Kumatora has ran off to.  Kumatora had left Lucas back in Tazmily to mature a bit while she went off looking for her friend Duster, who absconded with an important treasure, intuiting that the three of them have a destiny to fulfill.  As Lucas takes a stroll through town, he hears a few of the townsfolk talking about a club on top of the mountain with a bassist that looks a lot like the missing Duster.  He decides that his best course of action for reuniting with his lost friend and beginning to fight against the system that has been put in place since he was a child.

Reuniting with Kumatora and Duster, the group begins to seek out the treasure that Duster hid all those years ago.  This quest leads them to run into the Pig Mask Army, the main antagonistic force of Mother 3.  The Pig Masks are responsible for the urban development that has happened in Tazmily, introducing money to the once idyllic society and then providing all the goods and services that one would purchase with that money.  They are the military, government, and industry present on this once peaceful island, and their presence here reveals one of the dirtiest secrets that the faction is holding onto.  Far far out in the woods is a giant tower that they have been building for the past three years under the pretense it was a power plant.  While that is, certainly, one function of the structure the more pressing function is controlling the narrative.  This giant tower, commissioned by the mysterious head of the Pig Mask army, is designed to punish those who would dare have dissenting opinions by destroying their homes and putting an end to their traditional way of doing things.  It is a massive monument to the narcissism of the current regime, a regime that demands greed and rejects hope.  It is a symbol of everything Lucas and the gang hope to end.

Surprisingly, though, when Lucas begins his infiltration of the Pig Masks facilities he actually has a pretty easy time of it.  The Pig Masks seem to believe that Lucas is their leader, a young man who never shows his face but through context clues we can determine resembles Lucas a significant amount.  So much so that the majority of Pig Masks make this mistake, and it's only when a higher up gets involved that anyone notices the difference.  This stroke of good fortune allows Lucas and the gang to successfully sneak into the tower, and after fighting his way to the top, they manage to shut down the electricity to it, ending the Pig Mask Army's control over dissenting opinions once and for all.  Unfortunately for the gang, doing so also causes them to run afoul of the real leader of the Pig Mask Army, a mysterious figure known only as the Masked Man.  The gang is completely unable to stop the Masked Man, with his combat prowess and psychic abilities far outweighing their own.  Even the simple act of approaching him is nearly impossible, as he controls lightning with incredible ease.  Outmatched, the crew has no choice but to flee the tower, once again scattering them to the four winds.

Lucas ends up back in Tazmily Village, once again completely alone and completely directionless.  Consulting the townsfolk who still remember the old ways on what to do, Lucas is sent on a mission to locate the other race on this island, the Magypsies.  The Magypsies are a group of immortal beings who have served as guardians of the Nowhere Islands since time immemorial and who may very well hold the secret to unlocking a power strong enough to stop the Masked Man once and for all.  The first he meets grants him such a power, the power of PK Love, Lucas' signature psychic power.  They then set off to meet with a second Magypsy, only for said meeting to get cut short by the sudden disappearance of them before their very eyes.  It is here that we learn what is truly going on, the secret history of the Nowhere Islands and the true power of PK Love.

Long long ago, longer than anyone can remember, there existed a giant continent sized dragon.  This dragon had great potential to make the world a better place, but also had great potential to cause endless destruction and ruin.  So the decision was made to seal the dragon away, fearing the apocalypse that could be caused by its continued freedom.  It was nailed into the earth through seven enchanted needles and left to be buried and forgotten, the Magypsies being created to be the protectors of the needles.  But, sealing away such a creature seemed like such a waste, so the seal was designed to someday be broken.  When a chosen boy or girl is born, one who could harness the power of PK Love, the dragon could be awakened once again.  At which point its heart would reflect the heart of the chosen hero who unsealed it, be it a heart of creation or a heart of destruction.  Lucas IS that boy, the rightful wielder of PK Love.  There's just one problem: the Magypsies are meant to disappear after their corresponding needle gets pulled.  So who pulled the needle corresponding to their friend who just disappeared.  Why, who else, but the Masked Man.

That's right, the Masked Man also has the ability to use PK Love and, as such, can pull the needles out.  This is, obviously, an issue as the Masked Man is literally the leader of a fascist regime who hates all things natural and good and loves artificiality and money above all else.  There being 7 needles means that whoever successfully pulls four of the needles is given the right to shape the dragon's heart as they see fit.  Which means Lucas needs to find his friends quick and hunt down the remaining needles.  Our Magypsy friend gives us a direction to head, as they prepare to retreat to their own needle to await its pulling, excited and anxious about the oncoming end of their own life.  And so our hero sets off, reuniting with Kumatora and Duster along the way, sometimes beating the Masked Man to the needles and sometimes just barely missing out on being able to pull the needles themselves.  Eventually the score is 3-3, with the final needle, the needle located directly above the dragon's heart, still missing.  But before we can start hunting for it, we are interrupted by a representative of the Pig Mask Army.

This representative arrives to tell us that the "master" has invited us to his fortress, wherein the final conflict for the needle will take place.  The "master", as it turns out, has been enjoying the rat race between you and his "puppet", and so wants to ensure he can see the final battle take place for himself.  He has sent a limousine for his distinguished guests, rolling out the red carpet for his entertaining foes.  Our heroes are not given much of a choice in whether or not to board, the limo blocking every single exit from where the sixth needle rested.  So our gang must board the flying vehicle and prepare to go to the stronghold of the Pig Mask Army, the location where their true mastermind awaits.  The big city, a place where everyone has been moving to over the course of the game.  New Pork City.

Two things are striking about New Pork when you arrive.  The first is how much of a parody it feels like.  The city is a monument to excess in a way that makes it cartoonish.  It does not function like a real city, the floating stronghold is built on top of a labyrinth of tiny apartments while the facade of the city looks like a carnival.  A child's view of what a big city is, full of rides and toys and statues to them.  It paints the true villain as someone who loves himself a great deal.  The second thing that strikes you is who the statues are of.  Porky Minch.  Yes Porky, he was renamed from Pokey to Porky in Mother 3, don't worry about it.  Porky has, after all this time, fulfilled his promise to return and cause chaos in the world.  He has come to this idyllic world to prove that corruption is absolute, that mankind will always give into excess.  In a way, he is continuing the work of his own master, the great evil entity Giygas.  But whereas Giygas' corruption was more absolute, mankind giving into their darkest urges, Porky has a more targeted idea.  He was, after all, an insecure, spoiled brat.  And insecure spoiled brats want the entire world to be like them.

After allowing them some time to be appropriately horrified by his empire of excess, Porky calls the group to the massive skyscraper located in the center of town.  They go inside it to find it is very akin to the outside, a horrible collection of Porky's obsessions and twisted desires.  Floors of his monstrous chimeras, pleasure rooms devoted to the service of him staffed by androids, an obsessive collection of trinkets from the previous game in the series displayed as trophies, almost in mockery of his next door neighbor.  Like Ness' journey to defeat Giygas is now little more than Porky's trophy room.  As he reaches the top, Lucas finally meets the man himself, only to see he is a bitter, grey husk barely being kept alive by the machine he is now tied to and the hatred he feels for everyone and everything besides him.  He is the one who craves the wish, wanting to create a world where everyone is like him.  Greedy and arrogant and selfish.  He has orchestrated the transformation of the Masked Man, a boy he once found near dead in a ditch, with the specific purpose of making the world into what Porky desires.  And while Porky has enjoyed the entertainment of Lucas' battle with his puppet, the time for that is at its end.  Porky is here to kill Lucas, to make sure he is unable to pull the final needle.  So Porky pounces on him, causing Lucas and friends to fall through his skyscraper, fall down into the depths of New Pork City.  To fall to where the final needle is located.

The gang rushes to the final needle, attempting to prevent the worst outcome from passing.  While they are stopped by Porky along the way, who takes a page from his former master Giygas, having become something of an eldritch monster along the way, they defeat him swiftly.  Or, rather, convince him to hide with his tail between his legs, imprisoning himself in one of his own inventions that will keep him alive and completely safe forever but will never allow him to leave.  Porky always was a coward first and foremost, wasn't he?  With the final obstacle out of the way, Lucas and friends arrive at the needle just in time to stop the Masked Man.  It is here that we finally address the elephant in the room: the identity of the Masked Man.

So, when Lucas was young, he had gone up to visit his grandfather in the mountains north of their humble village with his mother and twin brother, Claus.  The night that they were expected home was the night that the Pig Mask Army, who had been operating on the island in secret for months, finally decided to show themselves for the first time.  This would lead to the tragic death of Lucas' mother, Hinawa, the first tragedy that the Tazmily villagers had seemingly ever faced.  In the aftermath of this, Claus would run away from the village to avenge his mother's death, to get stronger and face the monster that killed her and the people who turned a peaceful creature into a monster.  He, however, would never return.  The expectation being that he died as his mother did, although his family never gave up hope that he was still out there.  And, in a way, he was.  Claus' body, barely alive, was found by the Pig Mask army and, sensing the latent psychic power within him, he was converted into a cyborg puppet to be used as the mouthpiece for Porky Minch.

The Masked Man is Lucas' brother Claus.  Porky, through his experiments, has removed all sense of identity from the boy.  A perfect puppet to lead his armies in his stead and use his latent psychic energy to remove the needles.  Unable to recognize his own family, unable to even parse that he has one to recognize.  It seems the final conflict for the fate of the world will end in tragedy: one brother must kill the other to secure the future.  If Claus wins, the world becomes a reflection of Porky.  If Lucas wins, he can fix all the damage Porky's ideals have done to the world.  The two brothers square up for a final confrontation.  And it seems, for a fleeting second, Lucas will come out on top, the world will be saved.  But one problem arises at the final moments: Lucas can't do it.  He cannot kill his brother for the second time.  Lucas, who has known such tragedy in his entire life, cannot be the one to end the life of the brother he has only just found again.

So it seems the two will be locked into stalemate, Claus always attack, Lucas always recovering from the brink of death.  Until Lucas finally gives out, unable to compete with the machine his brother has become.  A hopeless outcome, one where Porky's ideals will always win in the face of goodness.  But there is never truly hopelessness is there.  Even in the darkest moments, hope will spring forward.  And in this moment, the voice of Lucas' dearly departed mother, Hinawa, begins filling the room.  Hinawa begs her boys to stop fighting, begs Claus to remember, to see the family he can no longer see.  And slowly, Claus' movements become hesitant.  Erratic.  The boy fighting against his programming at the sound of his mother's voice.  Until he stops completely.  Claus removes his helmet, to reveal the broken boy underneath.  He goes to his brother, embracing him one last time, before finally getting the rest he has been robbed for so long.  Dying in his brother's hands.  Saying goodbye to his brother, Lucas steps up and pulls the final needle, ensuring the world will not fall to Porky's ideals ever again.  But what form this new world will take, we will never know.  The characters of Mother 3 say their farewells to the player, as they stand on the precipice of this new creation, and we end the game with the hope that the world Lucas will create will be better.  Ending not just Mother 3, but the Mother franchise.  But what good is an ending, pray tell, if we don't know...

Earthbound Beginnings

This'll be the short part, another reason why it's good that I did this in this order.  In a franchise of black sheep, Earthbound Beginnings is the black sheep.  A fairly niche and arguably really outdated NES RPG, Beginnings leans the most away from its story and towards it just being a fun adventure in a version of America.  There are even entirely optional areas, places you do not need to go at any point in the journey but may have important items or even party members if you partake.  Making it seem way more like you're just wandering around the world, finding your own adventure.  Due to various similarities between Beginnings and it's sequel, some people have even stated that you don't need to play Beginnings as Earthbound somewhat replaces it.  Which is not true because outside of their structure and some of their theming, the two are nothing alike.  Beginnings doesn't have as much of Earthbound and Mother 3's sense of humor, instead being more serious and satirical than offbeat and funny.  And it is difficult, a rare trait for this trilogy as Earthbound and Mother 3 are both incredibly easy and accessible JRPGs.  Beginnings is like 50% grinding, a common trait for NES RPGs in general, they padded their runtime with grinding, but odd for Earthbound.  It is, a game that one could not blame another for skipping.  It is also a game that you need to play in order to understand what this trilogy is about.

Set in America in 1988, Earthbound Beginnings tells the story of Ninten, a young boy from the small town of Podunk in what appears to be California.  Ninten awakens one morning to find a disturbance in his home.  Various pieces of furniture and toys have mysteriously come to life, trying to attack his family for reasons currently unknown.  Defeating the living furniture and the phantom that cause them to come to life, a poltergeist that was set upon the family, Ninten quickly discovers that it is likely connected to the research of his great-grandparents, George and Maria, who studied supernatural and extraterrestrial sciences at the turn of the 20th century and whom disappeared mysteriously about 80 years prior, with only George ever returning.  Knowing that his family history is involved in this and seeing that the entire world has been thrown into chaos, Ninten sets out to discover what is causing these monsters to appear and how they can stop it and save the world.

Not too long into his journey, wanting to avoid a police roadblock, Ninten heads up into the mountains and discovers a portal to a mystical kingdom in the clouds called Magicant.  Exploring this mysterious kingdom causes him to stumble into the castle of the kingdom's ruler, a young woman named Mary.  Mary is pleased to meet the young boy, as she has had a vision of his arrival.  She's been having a lot of visions lately.  Her dreams have been plagued by dissonant fragments, maybe memories, maybe premonitions, but always accompanied by one specific element.  Scattered throughout the world, you see, in the sounds of various people, places and things, are hidden a melody.  A melody that belongs to Queen Mary.  If Ninten were to assemble such a melody, he could use it to fulfill the queen's request.  This becomes central to our quest, to find the scattered pieces of the melody and bring them back to the queen of Magicant, in the hopes that she will find out what they mean and use them to aid us in our quest to defeat the evil ravaging the world.

Ninten's journey takes him across a large swath of America (or at least the Pacific coast, it's heavily implied to just take place on the Pacific coast).  He meets new friends, Lloyd, a bullied child with a lot of brains and Ana, a sheltered rich girl with a missing mom.  He discovers that whatever is plaguing this world is more insidious than he could've ever imagined, kidnapping and murdering people in turn for its goals.  He fights gangs.  He befriends robots.  He has the kind of adventure that would fit in with the 80s family movies that people rave about to this day, very "movie that Drew Struzan would do a poster for" coded.  All the while, he collects the fragments of Mary's song.  This all comes to its natural close when he arrives at the final area of the game, Mt. Itoi, a massive mountain outside of Ellay which contains most of the secrets of his journey.

On Mt. Itoi, Ninten discovers his great-grandparents' lab.  In it there is a giant robot, designed to assist the young boy on his trek up the mountain.  George, his great-grandfather, apparently knew that someday Ninten would arrive to stop whatever is causing this world to become so chaotic.  Unfortunately, the robot encounters an enemy stronger than it, forcing it to sacrifice itself for Ninten.  Fortunately, it contains the final fragment of the melody needed to give to Mary to have her recall what she needs to recall.  With it obtained, the gang warps to Magicant to give Mary the song.  As Mary sings it, she remembers everything.  She is not Mary at all, you see, she is Ninten's great-grandmother Maria.  Having now been awakened, she tells the story of what happened during her disappearance.

The disappearance was actually one of their inventions successfully warping them to outerspace.  It was there that they met a young alien by the name of Giygas.  George and Maria fell in love with Giygas, and began to raise him as their own son.  But Giygas became paranoid and jealous, believing that his newfound family did not truly love him and were instead there to steal the secrets of his race, the secrets of psychokinetic power.  Furthermore, he was aware that a day would come when his beloved Maria would have to return home, and as such Giygas grew to despise the world she originated from.  Ninten's great-grandparents barely managed to escape, but only George would ever return home.  Maria was put into an eternal sleep, awaiting the one who could defeat Giygas to arrive so she could assist him.  With her duty fulfilled, Maria begins to disappear, Magicant going with her.  Leaving Ninten and friends to confront the alien at the core of the corruption of the world.

As Ninten approaches Giygas, he greets him as if they are old friends.  Ninten is, as far as Giygas sees it, the closest thing he has to family.  And, more importantly, Ninten is a family member with great psychic power, someone Giygas can truly view as an equal.  Giygas asks Ninten to return to his planet with him, to allow the destruction of Earth with him its only survivor.  When Ninten refuses, however, all pleasantries drop.  Giygas becomes aggressive, attempting to kill the insolent humans who dare think they can comprehend the sheer power of him.  And, indeed, it seems like Ninten and crew lacks a way to defeat this alien.  His technology is too advanced and his power is too absolute.  But then an idea pops in their heads.  They begin singing the song that awoke Maria.  A song of love.  A song she used to sing to Giygas as a lullaby.  The sheer emotion that overwhelms Giygas at hearing this song causes him to break down, a bullet piercing through the armor of hatred and contempt he wears constantly.  Giygas chooses to retreat, lest he be full destroyed by the music.  But he promises that someday he will return.  That he will harden his heart and once again destroy this world he despises so much.  For now, though, the day is saved.  And for our purposes, the trilogy is over.

What is the plot of the Mother trilogy?

Upon your first playthrough of the Mother trilogy, it can seem like Mother is, like many RPG franchises, anthological.  The Mother trilogy obviously has recurring antagonists, don't get me wrong, Giygas appears in both Beginnings and Earthbound and Porky appears in both Earthbound and Mother 3, and the games do make various nods to one another throughout their playtime.  But for the most part, the Mother trilogy seems unified in a more thematic sense.  Every game touches on very similar themes, the end of innocence, the importance of hope even when the world seems at its darkest, the corrupting influence of greed and cynicism, etc.  Shigesato Itoi intended the trilogy to be a satire and criticism of modern life, the thoughts of a man who believed the world was becoming too greedy, losing its substance in the face of the glamour of modernity.

But, I do think there is a singular central narrative a specific theme that makes the Mother series work.  Of course something deeper is going on within the Mother series, that's not very surprising.  The fact that the two main antagonists of the series, Giygas and Porky, both reoccur is obviously a deliberate choice.  But it could be parsed that the decision to never have the same cast otherwise is moreso about onboarding the player easier than having any real narrative weight.  That the overarching narrative is meant to be a story that is cool if you know the series and like seeing these antagonists recur, but is otherwise ignorable.  A way to ensure every Mother game could be your first and then if you dive in deeper on the series then the pieces come together.  But I actually think it's rather poignant that each game has an entirely unique cast, and that rather than being a way to lead players into discovering the overarching story, they are an incredibly significant portion of the overarching story.

Our story begins in Earthbound Beginnings, with George and Maria.  In the early 1900s, supernatural researchers George and Maria disappear from their home in the small town of Podunk, going missing for two years.  Their disappearance is due to discovering a portal to an alien world, somewhere far beyond the reach of planet Earth.  On the other side of this portal, they meet a young alien by the name of Giygas, an alien who was abandoned and is completely alone.  Giygas, you see, was born to be a conqueror.  And whatever race Giygas comes from, they believe that to breed conquerors, you must allow them to raise themselves alone.  George and Maria see the young alien and immediately fall in love with the poor child.  They take it upon themselves to raise this young creature, to show him the love that he is missing.

For a while, things were good.  Giygas loved his surrogate parents like any child would and George and Maria adored him with everything they had.  Unfortunately, though, a wedge would begin to form between Giygas and his parents.  He became aware of how different they were.  He was an extraterrestrial conqueror and they were of a planet far far away from his home.  He grew to resent the idea that, someday, they would have to return home, return to a family they left behind.  And while they likely assured him he was welcome to come with them, his nature made that an impossibility.  The people of Earth would never accept a monster like him in their midst.  He was jealous of a life he was unable to live.  Jealous of an Earth that would inevitably take everything from him.

This jealousy turned to paranoia.  George, always the researcher, had been asking questions of his son the entire time they were there.  He was fascinated by Giygas' race, a race that had unlocked all the secrets of the mind and learned to manifest thought into power.  As Giygas grew more jealous, more paranoid, though, he began to see these questions as malicious.  He believed that his father wanted to steal the secrets of his race, to bring them back to his planet and make them his own.  His paranoia turned once again, this time to hatred.  Giygas began to believe everything that his people had always said was true, that the universe is a cold, selfish, unfeeling place that was his to possess and subjugate.  And as his hatred grew, a distance grew as well between him and his parents.  Eventually, George and Maria had no choice but to flee from their son, seeing the monster he had become.  George made it back to his home planet of Earth, but Maria was never seen from again, having been caught in a place between places, a time between times.  George, sensing that his son would come back to finish what he had started, retreated to an old lab on Mt. Itoi just outside of Ellay.  It is here that he would begin work on a weapon to stop Giygas when he would arrive.  George would die on that mountain, his creation completed and awaiting the one who would stop his son's wrath.

Nearly a century then passes.  In that time, Giygas became the conqueror his people wished for him to become, fueled by the jealousy and hatred he had grown to feel during his time with George and Maria.  But his conquest had a specific target, a singular planet that he wished to personally subjugate and destroy.  That little blue marble, that insignificant speck in the universe that would take his family from him.  The planet Earth.  Giygas would land on Earth to begin his invasion, ironically stationing himself on the same mountain his father would die on, and begin a merciless assault.  He wanted the people of Earth to feel what he felt.  He abducted parents, leaving children to be orphaned as he once was, and would kill any resistance with a swift and decisive hand.  He would use his unending psychic power to throw the world into chaos.  His invasion force had one singular goal: to cause as much misery as possible.  And it is here that he ran afoul of a boy named Ninten.  Ironically a descendant of the man and woman who raised him.

This is where the main story of Earthbound Beginnings takes place as listed above.  Ninten finds the song for his great-grandmother, learns the secret history of his connection with Giygas, and arrives at the final confrontation with the alien conqueror.  Giygas greets the young boy as if they are old friends, perhaps feeling some sort of kinship with him as his "cousin", perhaps out of sentimentality to the one woman he doesn't completely hate, perhaps simply sensing Ninten's incredibly psychic power.  Giygas offers Ninten a chance to join him, to form an unstoppable duo to conquer the universe, to leave behind the planet Giygas intends to destroy.  As we know, though, Ninten will not budge, will not submit to the ideals of the conqueror.  And so, the two battle.

While Giygas' power seems truly insurmountable, so far beyond the understanding of Ninten and friends, an embodiment of the pure, all-consuming hatred he feels for everyone and everything, there is one element he never accounted for.  Maria.  As the group sings Maria's lullaby, Giygas reacts viscerally to it.  Screaming at them to stop and writhing around as if it is causing him physical pain.  To Giygas, hatred is absolute.  It is the driving force in everything he does.  But this simple song, this melody that Maria sang to him as a child, threatens to undo his entire worldview.  The hatred that has festered for nearly a century unable to stand up to the simple and pure power of a mother's love.  And as the song nears completion, Giygas acts in fear.  Fear that his empire will crumble because of the belief he buried long ago.  He has no choice but to retreat, to protect himself, to protect the hatred he clings so dearly to.  He abandons his conquest of Earth... for now at least.  But he makes Ninten a promise.  Someday, he will return to Earth to finish what he started.  And when that happens, Ninten, his friends, and his stupid song will not be around to stop him.

Giygas retreats to the far ends of the universe and awaits his destiny.  Festering in hatred for humanity for centuries.  Millennia.  Eons.  The universe warps and shapes around him, becoming old, then becoming new again.  He arrives in a new universe, one that fulfills his promise to Ninten.  One where there is no grand hero to stop him, no allies to aid them, and, most importantly, no Maria.  No lullaby to undo him yet again.  Giygas can now destroy the planet he despises so much without adversity.  Or, at least, that's what he thinks.  In the late 2000s/early 2010s, on this new Earth, Giygas mounts a large scale alien invasion with one goal in mind: destruction.  Complete and total destruction.  His original plan was too petty, too emotional.  Wanting the people of Earth to suffer as he suffered was arrogance, plain and simple.  Now he simply wants them to die.  But, despite what he believes about this new world, he is wrong that there are no heroes awaiting him.  A powerful psychic user named Ness, along with his friends Paula, Jeff, and Poo, arise to stop him.  Ending his invasion for good and almost defeating Giygas once and for all.

Mounting a tactical retreat, Giygas comes up with a new plan.  He will hide in the beginning of the universe, in a time unreachable by Ness and friends, and will restore himself utilizing a machine.  It is here, from a time beyond time, where he will command his army to invade once again.  But this time, the invasion will not be a grand scale conquest or a full destruction.  No, it'll be something far more clever than that.  He will send his forces to when Ness was a young boy, before his powers were unlocked and he was simply a child.  While he will take efforts to end Ness' life before it even starts, he has a different plan.  He will corrupt the world.  Utilizing statues and totems of his power, he will infect the world of Ness' childhood, turn it into a cruel, apathetic, greedy place.  He will conquer the places of safety scattered throughout the world, and leave behind only a place of contempt.  He will turn people into the worst versions of themselves, encourage them to give into their worst vices.  He will steal the world Ness would fight for before he even has a chance to fight for it.

Fortunately for our hero, his older self discovers this plan and, before his timeline would be erased, sends an ally back to the past to assist him.  Buzz Buzz arrives to tell the young Ness about Giygas and the attempts on his life.  How Giygas has infected the world and how he is attempting to steal Ness' childhood from him before he can even begin it.  Ness must travel the world, uniting the four heroes, rescuing the eight sanctuaries where he would've grown his power in the future.  This is where the story of Earthbound takes place within our little overarching story, Ness saving the world bit by bit, combating Giygas' corruption as he finds it, all the while Giygas watches from beyond time, believing Ness will never reach him even if he were to succeed.

Ness, however, is not the only person Giygas is watching.  Early on in Ness' journey, he is joined by his neighbor and frenemy Pokey Minch, not yet Porky, but also definitely is Porky and it's just a difference in how two different localization teams chose to localize the name.  Porky is cowardly, greedy, arrogant, spoiled, and just the perfect flavor of insecure.  In other words, he is exactly the kind of puppet Giygas needs to pull his strings for him.  A boy who will run towards the kind of power Giygas offers rather than trying to fight it.  After a bad encounter with his abusive father, Porky runs away from home and, incidentally, towards Giygas.  First finding himself joining the Happy Happyist Cult in Peaceful Rest Valley, where he serves as the right hand man to the head of the cult, Mr. Carpainter.  Then as the assistant to Mayor Monotoli.  Before finding himself in the dark swamps of the Southern continent, close to Giygas' final stronghold.  Everywhere where it would appear that Giygas' corruption is most strong, Porky Minch somehow finds his way there.  Giygas' perfect little puppet, a mouthpiece for him beyond space and time.

It is then, perhaps, unsurprising that when Ness arrives to face Giygas once and for all, Porky is there.  Or rather, a man who once was Porky.  The corruption of Giygas has changed him.  His skin has turned a deep gray, like a stone statue.  He simultaneously looks like a young boy and an old man.  He has become giant, monstrous, grotesque.  He is now fully an extension of his master's ideals.  He feels as Giygas feels.  He wants as Giygas wants.  He hates as Giygas hates.  He speaks of Giygas with a religious fervor, treating his master as not only the conqueror of the universe, but as the universe itself.  He adores him and fears him in equal measure, and finds great entertainment in the sheer audacity of these humans believing they can take on a god.  A god who, in his obsession with Ness and his psychokinetic healing, has ironically become a reflection of the very hero he despises.  His entire body turning into a vessel of Ness' essence.  He is far beyond rational thought anymore, all Giygas knows is hatred.

The gang then gets to work, destroying Giygas' machine and destabilizing his very essence.  Giygas is no longer a corporeal entity at all, he is psychokinetic essence in its purest form.  An entity with no wants, no thoughts, no feelings.  Just hatred.  Just pain.  If the Giygas Ninten fought seemed insurmountable, this Giygas seems like the apocalypse given form.  As the gang attempts to stop the sheer unadulterated hatred flowing through, it seems impossible.  Giygas is everything.  And they don't have a lullaby to soothe his soul this time.  But so long as they are alive, they have hope.

Paula reaches out through space and time, reaches towards the people who they have met upon their journey, and asks them to give them their strength.  The sheer, unadulterated feeling of love, the love of an Earth wanting to save those who would sacrifice themselves to save it, is too much for Giygas.  He begins to slowly dissipate, the hatred he represents dissolving into nothing.  It starts small, a few people giving them their strength, but balloons into the entire planet.  This unstoppable, overwhelming love is what destroys Giygas once and for all, ending eons of suffering and hatred and corruption.  The group runs off as his true fortress collapses, and Porky seems to be cast to the winds, never to be seen again.

That is, until a letter appears in Ness' mailbox, promising the return of him, promising that he will get his revenge.  Giygas may be gone, you see, but the hatred he represented has simply found his way to a new vessel.  Unfortunately for us, this new vessel is not some alien conqueror with no emotions and a singleminded ambition.  Oh no.  This new vessel is a petulant, arrogant, self-serving spoiled brat.  And the hatred he feels will manifest in some true, unadulterated horror, the kind of horror that you can only imagine when you are a child with incredible power but no empathy.  Which brings us to our third and final game, Mother 3.

It is easy to think of Giygas as the ultimate evil at the center of this franchise.  A physical embodiment of a hatred that lasted for eons, so long that universe reset around it.  But what if you took that hatred, that pure unadulterated evil and concentrated it onto a little boy who has been equal parts spoiled and abused.  My friends, you would get Porky Minch.  The main antagonist of Mother 3.  Porky takes several notes from his master in how he conducts his plans.  Much like Giygas, he waits at the end of the universe, awaiting a reality where none will oppose him.  Much like Giygas, he wants to corrupt the world to create one where any opposition to his whims would cease to exist before they could hope to oppose him.  Unlike his master, however, Porky does not crave the destruction of the world.  He is not driven by an all-consuming jealousy, a contempt for the world that stole everything from him.  Oh no, to the contrary, Porky wants the world to remain in existence.  What Porky wants is for the world to think and act like him in every possible way, shape or form.

Porky's machinations have been in the works for a while, so long that he is essentially not human anymore.  His body exists as a husk, being kept alive by the machine he rests within, unable to even move his own hands.  He has been traveling across the universe for who knows how long, corrupting the world, collecting the things he craves from it, reshaping it to reflect him.  It has, if anything, become tiresome.  He wants a challenge.  Something that will be fun.  And that's where he discovers the Nowhere Islands, an Island chain populated by people who fled here on a boat to escape a dying world, a world that had succumbed to its vices.  Porky is delighted that such a place exists, a place to prove that humanity is always the same, they will always fall to greed.  But, Porky discovers something else from one of the Magypsies, the one dissenter in their ranks.  This Magypsy tells Porky that soon a boy will come with the power to pull the needles scattered across the islands.  Whoever pulls the needles will be granted the power to reshape the world in truth.  Porky, always one to want everyone to be as corrupt as him, is delighted by this prospect.  A world of Porky Minches.  A world of greed.  A world of hatred.

This is where the Mother 3 section of our story would take place.  Porky finds the young boy Claus and turns him into his puppet, a puppet with the power to pull the needles from the dragon's back.  The heroes race to stop him, only for Porky to imprison himself in an invention designed to keep him alive but imprisoned for all eternity.  Lucas and Claus have a final battle over the fate of the world, and in that battle, their dearly departed mother urges the two to stop fighting, urges Claus to let go, to come home to his family.  And Claus stops.  Despite all that Porky has done to him, he never could've anticipated this.  How could he?  Porky has never truly experienced love, only a vague sense of belonging.  He could've never anticipated that his utterly foolproof brainwashing would be undone by something so simple, so pure.  That, just like Giygas before him, his best laid plans could not stand up to a mother's love.  And so Claus returns to his family, saying goodbye to them one last time, before finally getting the rest he was robbed of for so long.  And Lucas uses the power of PK Love to create a brand new world.  A world that, we are sure, will try its best to be good.  After all, was it not created with love?

There Shouldn't Be An Official Mother 4

This all feels rather pointless in the grand scheme of things, doesn't it?  The Mother series has been over for 20 years now.  The series' creator, Shigesato Itoi, retired not just from the series but from all game development after the third entry, choosing instead to focus on writing and stationary.  Nintendo would have no reason to ever try and create a Mother 4, as it's an incredibly niche franchise in their legacy whose relevancy has been bolstered by an admittedly passionate community and a prominent appearance within Super Smash Bros.  It's not even the most popular first party JRPG franchise they have, Fire Emblem and Xenoblade Chronicles are both significantly more popular than the Mother franchise in both the short and long terms.  And even if they wanted to, they couldn't, as while they own the trilogy itself, they do not own Mother as a franchise.  Mother belongs to Itoi, he holds the IP, and Itoi is not interested in returning to game development and, if anything, seems to believe Mother belongs to the people, not him.

Not only that, but there's not really a widespread fan want for an official Mother 4.  Again, the fanbase already essentially owns Mother, they can just make it themselves.  And lord knows several people have tried.  It doesn't make sense for anyone to really demand a Mother 4 from Itoi and Nintendo?  It would be an entirely selfish want, a desire sprung forth from the need to consume more Mother content rather than to love Mother as a trilogy of artistic works.  It would serve no one to "get the band back together" in this case, as "the band" is primarily comprised of very old men who haven't worked in the games industry in decades.  Granted, I think every fan has that moment of being like "it would be cool if Itoi came back and made Mother again", lord knows I sure do.  But it is not only not realistic, but, frankly, I think the Mother series would be worse off if it did happen.

Mother is a rare series that is allowed to do something that seems to be less and less common nowadays: it's allowed to end.  It is one continuous storyline, the story of a universe in peril, a story of all powerful threats that seem beyond comprehension, and the brave heroes who face them anyways.  It is one singular thing, a story told across three entries that does not need addition.  You could, hypothetically, build off the ending of Mother 3 and do another game mind you.  Porky is still around, even if he's forever trapped in a prison of his own design, the universe just reset with the shape it is going to take unknown, and I think a lot of people would just like to see some of these characters again.  If Itoi decided tomorrow he was going to come out of retirement as a game dev because he really wanted to do another one of these, found a new angle to make Mother work, I'm sure there would be something he could do with it.  I'm sure it would even be great.  However, I think there is something very poignant about how the overall story of Mother ends in 3, and I think a fourth entry would only take from it rather than build on it.

What is the recurring motif at the center of the Mother series?  Hating cops.  Okay, besides that?  Government figures are incompetent and will take credit for other people's work at every opportunity, especially during election years.  Okay, besides THAT?  The big city is a monument to excess that only seeks to pervert the natural order and rob people of innocence.  Okay, there are a lot of motifs at the center of Mother, Itoi has a lot of opinions about modernity.  But what is the one I've been getting at for this entire essay?  ...Capitalism bad.  Okay, look, I'm just going to tell you, the Mother series' main overarching theme is the power of love overcoming the seemingly endless depths of greed, jealousy, paranoia and hatred.  That is what every single Mother game is about.  It is what the actual plot keeps getting to and its honestly why this series is called Mother in the first place.  I mean it's called mother for a lot of reasons, including referencing motherships and John Lennon, but like within the text of the game, the theme of love overcoming all is why the series is called Mother.

In the first game, Giygas' primary motivation for wanting to ruin Earth is his jealousy, paranoia, and contempt for the people on it.  As stated, he views Earth as a planet that only wishes to take from him.  He believes that the power of psychokinesis is something that rightfully belongs to his race and he believes that the Earthlings coming in and attempting to study it is, in fact, a theft of his people's knowledge.  He believes this so strongly that he was willing to turn against his father, a man who raised him with love and compassion, for being a thief and a liar.  Even when Ninten faces Giygas for the first time, Giygas feels a lingering affection for Maria but holds nothing but hatred in his heart for George, still believing him to be a thief.

Moreover, though, Earth to Giygas is a place that wishes to steal his parents away from him.  It is the world they rightfully belong to, the world they will have to go back to.  Maria, the only thing Giygas seems to truly love, is only his temporarily.  And Giygas hates Earth for it, hates this planet that he had not known existed in the first place.  This leads him to mount a large scale invasion, punishing the population for what he believes it took from them.  He kidnaps and murders people, uses his power to interrupt the natural order and make animals and plants go wild, and even plays with the very order of life and death.

Yet, all this carnage, all this oppression, it cannot stand up to a simple lullaby.  Deep down, somewhere far deeper than Giygas even knew his heart could go, is still a child.  A child who wants his mother.  And he physically cannot handle the reality of that fact.  Cannot handle that he still loves, truly loves, in a way he thought was impossible for him.  His entire invasion undone by a simple song.  And rather than face what he feels, Giygas flees, feeling the love that undid him so decisively is simply a flaw he must overcome.  But the truth still stands: Giygas was defeated by something as simple and pure as a mother's love.

In Earthbound, he attempts to create a world where such a love cannot exist.  Create a world that is so greedy, so selfish, so full of his hatred that it cannot produce the love necessary to stop him.  To steal the power that would put an end to his reign once and for all before it can even blossom.  And it seems like he succeeds, at least at first.  The world of Earthbound is corrupt, it does have a lot of selfishness in it.  It is a world where it seems kindness is a rarity, a world where people are so angry and resentful that grown adults will harass children for the simple crime of walking.  His plan seems absolute, so much so that it spawned forth something of a cult to him, whether or not they knew they were worshipping him.  It even created a successor.

And yet, despite his best efforts, he accomplishes nothing.  Ness is able to go through the world, is able to find the places where he would be safest.  He defeats Giygas' plans at each juncture, using his wit, but also, most importantly, his kindness.  Giygas' reign of terror, a plan he had been putting in motion since the beginning of Ness' universe, is undone by the kindness of four children who just wish to help people.  He believed he had defeated the love that once threatened to defeat him, and yet Giygas did nothing but create a world that needed the kindness he thought he could suppress.  And in the end, this kindness was what undid him.  The love of an entire world, unified by four children, was capable of destroying an entity who had spent two entire universes hating.  But, the scars of this hatred lived on.  Giygas' very own protege, Porky Minch, was not swayed by this unified world.  He was, after all, too selfish for that.

Porky Minch wanted a world that was exactly like him.  And so he found a way to achieve it.  He would bend and break the rules of space and time more times than anyone could count, building an army that thinks, acts, and wants only what Porky would want.  He was really into his former master's plan, you see, corrupting the world in its totality to reshape it to your desires.  But Porky realized something Giygas didn't: humans don't like being manipulated.  If they discover they are being so, they will rebel.  No, to really make sure that their loyalty is absolute, you need to make their corruption feel like their own idea.  Make it so that it is them who is selling their own souls to you.  And that is exactly what Porky did.

Porky made people believe their lives were lacking, despite being perfectly happy and content with everything beforehand, all to sell them things that would make their lives more "fulfilling".  He preyed on curiosity and good faith to sell them things that were, in fact, making their lives worse, under the pretense of making them better.  He didn't try to control, he allowed people to give him control of their own volition.  All while orchestrating his true plan: to harness the power of creation and create a world of Porky Minch in earnest.  One where people weren't just like him, but truly were identical to him.  A world of greed and selfishness and pure unadulterated hatred.

This leads him to the creation of a puppet, a puppet who will be able to use the psychokinetic power he so sorely lacks and rewrite the world as he desires.  He strips the puppet's identity, memories, in some ways his very soul from him.  Instead turning him into a perfect robot for Porky's ambitions.  A surrogate dictator to command his armies and enact his plans while Porky prepares his "utopia".  But, like his master before him, Porky fails to understand the sheer power of love.  He thinks it is foolish, something people will willingly give up for wealth and power and belonging.  Love, to Porky, is just a programming error, something natural that he can oppress like everything else.

But when it comes down to it, the reason his puppet cuts his strings is due to the very thing that almost undid his master, the very thing that this series is named after.  A Mother's love.  Hinawa is able to come to her son's aid, guiding him back from what Porky did to him, guiding him to his family.  Allowing him to finally rest after being forced to live half-alive for many years.  The best laid plans finally undone with a simple act of pure, unadulterated love.  And it is that same love Lucas uses to pull the final needle and fix all that is broken.  Literally, the psychic power that Lucas wields is titled "PK Love".  Love overcomes hatred, and finally, at the end of Mother 3, the cycle is broken.  Porky is a prisoner of his own machinations, he left behind no successor.  Giygas is long gone.  And our heroes are allowed to create a new world, one of love.  Claus being called home by his mother is the end of the Mother series.  The end of a cycle that fed through countless universes and three whole games.  The ending of a story.

If Mother 4 were ever to be made, I'm sure it would be good.  It may even be great.  It won't be made for what it's worth, Itoi understands the narrative he wrote is done and like I said, he has been out of the games industry for decades.  The only way it is likely to happen is if somehow Nintendo gets ahold of the Mother franchise and decides to greenlight a new game since it is one of their big iconic franchises, which is also unlikely.  But I don't think a Mother 4 would ever work out ultimately.  Because what Mother is, that's done.  It's a beautiful story of love overcoming all told over three games, one that has reached its conclusion.

A Mother 4 would, at best, be "a fun Mother game" and at worst would actively take away from the trilogy by its existence.  A story that ended now suddenly having no ending.  To continue Mother would only serve to weaken it.  There shouldn't be an official Mother 4.  To do so would be gravely misunderstanding what Mother is, what it meant to accomplish, and how it accomplished it.  It would be against everything Mother stands for.  And this trilogy is too important to just get thrown to the wayside like that, to be turned into yet another avenue for "content" for a major game company.  I understand it's tempting sometimes, sometimes I sit there and wish there was more.  More of this thing I love.  But it needed to end, and it's good that it ended.  It's stronger because it ended.